Where is the best blueberry pie?

Question

I know everyone has different tastes, but I'm looking for not super sweet pie, and bonus points if it comes with ice cream. And, does anyone make a blueberry crumble? The trip is 2 weeks away, and I'm getting hungry!

Answer

If you're craving blueberry pie in Bar Harbor or anywhere on Mount Desert Island, you're in for a treat! There are several great spots that serve delicious blueberry pie, and some even offer a less-sweet option that might suit your taste. Plus, a few places might even serve it with ice cream or offer blueberry crumbles. Here are some top recommendations:

Jordan's Restaurant – Known for its homestyle cooking and blueberry pie, Jordan's serves a more traditional, slightly less sweet pie, making it a great choice if you're looking for something more balanced. It's a local favorite, and you can often find it served with vanilla ice cream, which is a nice bonus!
Jeannie's Great Maine Breakfast – This spot in Bar Harbor offers a delicious homemade blueberry pie, often served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The pie is well-loved for its fresh, flavorful filling and flaky crust. Jeannie's is also known for its breakfast and brunch offerings, so it’s a great spot to stop in for dessert after a meal.
Mount Desert Island Ice Cream – While not known specifically for pies, this local ice cream shop is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth. They offer a variety of delicious homemade ice creams, and during blueberry season, they have blueberry flavors that pair perfectly with your pie if you're looking for an ice cream addition.
Beal's Lobster Pier – While this is more of a seafood place, their blueberry pie is definitely worth mentioning. It's fresh, not overly sweet, and has a great balance of tartness from the berries. Many visitors enjoy their pies along with a side of Maine’s famous vanilla ice cream.
Little Notch Bakery – This bakery in nearby Southwest Harbor is known for making amazing fruit pies, including blueberry. They sometimes offer a blueberry crumble pie, which is a nice twist on the classic version. It's a favorite for those who enjoy a crumbly topping and a slightly less sweet filling.
The Blueberry Muffin – Located in Bar Harbor, this quaint bakery makes a delicious blueberry pie. It’s not too sweet, and the blueberries are ripe and flavorful. They offer both traditional pie and sometimes a crumble topping, depending on the day, so you may get lucky if you're craving that particular dessert.

Whether you prefer a traditional pie or a crumbled version, you’ll find some fantastic options in and around Bar Harbor. Make sure to ask for ice cream to top off your dessert if that’s something you enjoy! Enjoy your trip, and I hope you find the perfect blueberry pie to satisfy your cravings!

Where is the best blueberry pie?

More Bar Harbor Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions