5Church Buckhead Reviews

Our group had a fabulous brunch at 5 Church in the Buckhead area of ATL. The oysters were fresh and came with three different options/flavors to add on top. I really enjoyed the Steak & Eggs dish as well as the Benedict! The mimosas are $5 and you can switch out orange juice for other flavors like cranberry. Our table also enjoyed the espresso martinis and bloody mary’s. The environment is full of art and stunning views! You won’t be disappointed sitting at any table in the restaurant because there is so much to look at.

They do not like children. They sit children in the worst part of the restaurant and do not allow them to sit in the nice area of the restaurant. They basically ignored my table the whole time I was there.

The ambiance is beautiful! Precious took our drink orders and checked in with us (she was very sweet). The food was just OK. I wasn’t impressed at all! My food had to be sent back because it was lukewarm and the waitress (Lara) looked as if she was annoyed (that didn’t sit well with me). The food came out again and the sausages were cold, the steak was still lukewarm and the potatoes had extra salt on them (sounds like someone tried to be malicious). The manager came to our table (Valerie-very nice and personable) and asked us if things were ok. I explained what happened and she had my food remade but the eggs weren’t cooked to my liking the so I didn’t both eating them. The grits were very clumpy (it looked as if they weren’t completely cooked) so we just sent them back and told them we didn’t want them at all. I highly doubt if I ever return here, this was not a good experience at all.

First time at 5 Church but went here on a recommendation from a business colleague. Very good meal and extremely pleasant service, which was greatly appreciated. The menu had good choices, especially the short ribs. The Caesar salad, that was served before the entree, was plentiful. Also, enjoyed the selection of drinks. Although a chain restaurant, 5 Church was a very nice experience.

I had heard great things about 5 Church Buckhead and was super excited to try it! Unfortunately, it was a disappointing experience. The food was actually good, but given the poor service, we won't return. As soon as I arrived, I stood in line to be checked in. The host (a younger guy wearing an extremely casual red polo shirt) was super friendly to the two couples ahead of me. When I reached the host stand, he just glared at me without speaking. I told him the name on the reservation and he nodded and walked me to a table, then walked off. During the entire encounter, he never greeted me or said a single word. I felt so uncomfortable that I started Googling other restaurants nearby to see if we could get a last-minute reservation somewhere else. A few minutes later, my friend arrived and said that when she came into the restaurant, the host told her that no one had checked in for our reservation. He left her standing by the door and she eventually found me on her own. I informed the manager, who seemed totally indifferent. The waitress was very kind but we waited ages for our food. As it turns out, the restaurant had forgotten our appetizer. The waitress apologized profusely and comped the appetizer plus provided two glasses of Prosecco, which we appreciated. Generally, my impression was that 5 Church really wants to be a fine dining establishment but the staff (or the staff training) just isn't up to par. The food was pretty good, but it's simply not worth the unpleasant experience. We won't be back.

Food, drinks, and service was amazing. I definitely recommend the Twisted Tree cocktail. It was so good I ordered seconds! I will be back!

We visited this location during brunch service. Our valet attendant was great, he noticed us when we turned off the main road and waved us into the lot. We had reservations, were greeted immediately and sat shortly after. The sunroom is beautiful definitely would recommend sitting there! The service was okay, and food arrived in a timely matter. The sushi tots were 10/10, they are a must try if you like sushi. Shout-out to the valet attendant again when we left, he told us to stay in the hallway since it was very chilly outside and when leaving opened even the passenger door for me. It’s always the small things!

Was in town for a large cooperate meeting and popped in with a few coworkers. We have been traveling from city to city and this place has the best service I've encountered. The food and ambiance are equal amazing. This place is a must try.

modern, sleek with so many amazing art on the walls. Food is excellent and staff are extremely friendly.

We went to 5Church last night with a couple friends, and it's safe to say that we'll be back. I had the ceviche and halibut, which were both to die for. The art is gorgeous and the service was prompt and friendly. Overally, an excellent meal.

Great experience. Best steak in the city. Thank you. Chef Angelina delivered my delicious steak with a smile. Thanks Chef

My wife and I stopped in for drinks and appetizers at the bar. The bartenders are very knowledgeable and great at making suggestions. I had the vegetarian risotto which was amazing. They also have it as a lobster risotto. My wife had the wagyu burger and said it was also really good especially with the brioche bun soaked in duck fat. We will have to be back to try their brunch menu!

Met with brother and his wife recently at 5Church. Valet parking only. Dined in their indoor sunroom area for Saturday Brunch. Little loud due to extra large crowds but still had a good time with great service and food. We ate the chicken and waffles and French omelet dishes. Yummy! Recommend you try it out if in the area. Maybe try another time during the week if you want less noise.

We came, had couple cocktails (I recommend the sun tzu and the twisted tree), and a few appetizers(the land and sea was my fav, but I only snagged a picture of the mussels before people dug in) All I can say is that I’m not sure how the buckhead food scene coped before 5Church. I can’t wait to come back hear for a full meal!

Im already A big 5church fan, so i came to try their new social hour menu. They exceeded my expectations like they always do. The citrus salad and sliders are a must try!

After much hype for a corporate event, the portions were small and many attendees left hungry. Atmosphere was nice and the staff were very good. Portions of my butcher cut steak were tough and not edible. The bar also ran out of my favorite liquor when I ordered my 2nd drink.

love the food and art work! definitely recommend the bone marrow, land and sea and the chicken entree! 10/10 highly recommend

I had a great experience at 5Church Buckhead. I ordered the Cacio E pepe, and the Halibut. The food was delicious and I really enjoyed my experience at 5Church. If you are in the Buckhead, this is a great spot for dinner. The drinks are exceptional, and I love dining here! Definitely check it out

I sat in the Sunroom and had a great time! For lunch, I tried the Salmon Burger. Its my favorite with roasted tomatoes. The service was great, and they also offer Valet Parking.

I loved everything about this place.from the complimentary valet, to the beautiful ambience, the bathroom had a nice touch all the ladies were coming in there to take pictures. I booked it for my best forensic birthday and she loved everything about it! Definitely check it out you won't regret it! The manager was really sweet, she checked in us and made sure we were okay and the waitress wen t above and beyond even telling us the history about the place. 100/100 loved it!!!

I visited this location a few nights ago with friends. The atmosphere was great. However, the service was lacking. They were very inattentive. Also, the day after eating here I have never been so sick. I’m not saying it was for sure the food here but, I fairly sure it was. I would not recommend this establishment.

Exceeded expectations. Cocktail menu and preparation exceptional: all syrups house made with unique ingredients. Food all really good-lamb burger, crab cakes and veal loin.

The ambiance at 5Church is something eveyone should experience. In every corner you look there is beautiful art. There are so many menu items to explore, I can't wait to try them all. The bone marrow is AMAZING. I ordered the cacio e pepe pasta, it was the best l've ever had! Staff is very attentive, friendly and have a lot of knowledge. So glad there is something new in the neighborhood!

Me and my friends were visiting from LA and wanted to check them out. The cocktails tasted great the sunroom was super cute and had really nice decor/vibes

Absolutely beautiful, staff are attentive, food is super fresh and tasty. People are beautiful and well dressed. Ordered the veal chop, excellent! 5church Buckhead captured our attention, we will be back for more!!

I decided to take my family out to 5 Church Buckhead for dinner. It was absolutely amazing. The food was delicious and the service was just great. Not only that but it is such a beautiful restaurant, the art and ambience is just wonderful. This is a must go to in Atlanta. Great food, beautiful art, and great service. Definitely will be going back again.

I had lunch here today and it was amazing! The chicken is a must have. The service was excellent as well and the restaurant is absolutely beautiful. I will be back!

Because we love 5Church in Midtown, we opted to host a private company dinner at the new location in Buckhead. EPIC FAIL!!!! This new Buckhead location needs more time to get its act together. We had colleagues fly in from all over and planned on spoiling them with an exquisite meal and experience at 5Church Buckhead. Not only did everything go horribly wrong, but the solution they offered us a week after the fact was $500 for our next event. Let me break this down for you... We paid $130 per person for 16 people. That is $2,080 for just food, not including beverages and they think we would be enticed to roll the dice on another horrible experience and potentially embarrass ourselves again in front of another group of colleagues, by giving them another chance and spending more money there (minus the $500 gift card). ABSOLUTELY NOT! Here's what happened... Our contract was set for 6:00 PM-8:00 PM on a Tuesday. Our coordinator arrived at 5:45 PM to make sure everything was set for us. Upon her arrival, she was told we couldn't be seated until 6:30 PM. She pulled up the contract on her phone which clearly stated 6:00 PM. This was an IMMEDIATE red flag that they were NOT prepared to provide us with adequate service. As guests trickled in, we lined up at the bar to get drinks until they got our tables together. We weren't seated until 6:15 PM and our guests that did not get to order drinks at the bar weren't greeted at the table until 6:30 PM. We literally sat there watching the servers wander around trying to figure out what to do. Once we ordered drinks at 6:30 PM we started to get the appetizers around 6:45 PM. Please note... we had a pre-selected menu for everything to be plated family style so there wasn't a need for them to take any orders other than drinks. If our dinner was supposed to start at 6:00 PM why are we getting appetizers at 6:45 PM??? As the appetizers came out, we noticed one of the plates never actually came out to the 2nd table. When we let them know they put in an additional order. They literally placed an ADDITIONAL ORDER. They didn't say we'll bring that right now, they literally added an additional appetizer to our bill at the end of the night as if it wasn't included in our contract. Before receiving this missing appetizer they brought out our salads. Once we finished our salads they brought out the missing appetizer (which was the 2nd in the contract, but billed us as if it were the 3rd). Immediately after getting this appetizer, they started bringing out the food. o The steak (which we requested to be cooked medium) was cooked more of what I would describe as medium well. NO PINK o The salmon that was served at my table was cold and didn’t taste good. o We had to send an order of creamed spinach back because there was a “METAL TWIST TIE” in it! This happened at the same table of guests that waited for the goat cheese fritters. My thought is... if they cooked the spinach with the twist tie on it, did they even wash it first? Hardly anyone ate the overcooked steaks or cold salmon. By the time they brought out a new bowl of creamed spinach, we didn't even want it. GROSSED OUT The desserts were definitely not shareable among our large party. Honestly, the table of guests that waited for the goat cheese fritters and spinach was over it and didn’t touch their dessert tray. Macaroon cookies and bite-size squares of who knows what, nothing was explained to us. The best dish was the mashed potatoes and considering we spent $130 per person just on food alone, that is RIDICULOUS! Regular menu pricing: NY Strip $43 or $55 (10 or 14oz) Salmon $25 per person Sides range from $6-$8 dollars We could have saved OVER 1/2 of our money had we just ordered from the regular menu. I'm pointing this out because this SAME GROUP went to St. Cecilia's the night before, was taken care of by just 2 servers and we ordered everything from the regular menu. Everything came out promptly, including drinks. We had an AMAZING time and quite honestly, appreciated that dinner even more after experiencing this disaster.

My son and I went there for dinner on a sunday night because we were staying in The Waldor Astoria, which is opposite the road and saw it and had good reviews. We were surprised the waiter, who was very nice, didnt know about Bombay Saphire gin or FeverTree tonic water…he had no idea what we were talking about, he had to go 2 times to talk to the barman in order to tell us if they had them for a gin tonic. We had a Wagyu Burger and a Rib Eye, both very good, however the french fries were not good, very greasy. Overall our dinner was ok…I wouldnt go back but it was ok. Not cheap though…

Came to have a girls night out and everything was amazing! Staff, ambience, food, and drinks TOP TIER !!

Had a very nice Sunday "Buckhead Brunch" at 5 Church in early October. Everything from the valet parking, to the music, the decor, and the vibe was very "Buckhead." If you've live in Atlanta metro and have frequented many of the restaurants north of midtown, you know what I mean. I tried the Gashouse Egg Florentine and substituted a scrambled egg for the poached one. It was very tasty and not too heavy. The mimosas were good as well and at a decent price. The restaurant also has a beautiful glass patio area that was closed when we arrived. It's my understanding that in order to sit in this space, it is a $75 minimum per person. A little pricey and overboard if you ask me. Especially when you consider that the patio is facing another building and does not have what I would describe as a premium view. Certainly not worthy of the price tag. Not sure why they feel they needed to make it so exclusive. Anyway, be sure to bring a jacket or sweater if you visit because the temperature was very cold inside.

Love this spot! We came here for Valentine's Day Dinner and the restaurant did not disappoint. We originally came here in November 2023 and had an amazing brunch. This time we had dinner and had a wonderful time. Our server Jeff was awesome and thoroughly described the meals that we were interested in. This is the second time we had him as our server and were impressed with his service both times. The restaurant gets a 10 out of 10 for atmosphere, food, and service!