Hartley Kitchen & Cocktails Reviews

We stayed over in Atlanta because our flights were cancelled on Christmas Eve. We went for Christmas brunch and were shocked at the brunch cost (unpublished on the website, and we learned once we took a Lyft there). The morning shift staff essentially ignored us (including the two “manager-types” who walked by our table several times), and we had to flag someone down for coffee. The new waitstaff team that came was much friendly and offered to fill our coffees! Buffet style brunch, and so the automatic service gratuity was also quite high given the self-service. Food was good (kudos to the chefs) but wow. It was a really expensive (overpriced) meal!

The deviled eggs with truffles were very tasty. The seared redfish was excellent, but the absolute best part of the meal was the Butterscotch and Pear dessert.

The bar and the bartenders was terrific. Service and drinks were A+. The food was poor. I tried the tagliatelle with asparagus pesto. It was inedible. Drowning in oil. I rarely send food back, but this dish went back. So the bar gets five stars and the food gets no stars

My husband and I had reservations at Hartley recently and even though there was a mix-up with our reservation, they made it all right and treated us like royalty! The service was amazing and all of the wait-staff was so friendly and kept checking on us. We ordered the deviled eggs for appetizer (YUM!!) and then we both ordered the pan-friend trout with brussel sprouts/sweet potato hash. It also came with fuji apple salad and the flavors of the entire dish were sublime. This restaurant is simple fab and we will be back. They have both valet parking and the parking deck is easily accessible and a 2 minute walk to the front door. I'm serious - run don't walk to this restaurant. It is NOT to be missed.

We tried this restaurant for the second time and had a wonderful dinner. The restaurant is located in the new Kimpton Shane in Atlanta midtown. My NY strip dry aged steak was just perfect and the burger absolutely delicious. The deviled eggs were so tasteful and the banana cream desert a great presentation and finish for the dinner. Thank you

We had a delicious dinner and a great time. The food was absolutely on point. The service with Finn was delightful and he was always right there for any request and questions. So thank you Finn and Sam for making our Valentine's dinner so memorable and special. We will be back. ❤️💕❤️💕❤️💕❤️💕❤️

Good food during my six night stay. Free breakfast so was able to try a few dishes. The Hartley Breakfast was okay. Enjoyed the Griddled Breakfast Burrito and the Southern Omelette the most, both good portion size and tasty. Try their double patty Wagyu Beef Burger with freshly cooked house fries. Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail was pretty good too.