Montesacro Pinseria Reviews

A wonderful Saturday outing with family! Ambiance (lovely back garden room), service (shout out to Daniel!) and food (a nice variety which could accomodate our group) were all great! Thanks for a terrific brunch!

Montesacro Pinseria was a great neighborhood find for pizza ... Romano style. While we like traditional New York style pizza, the antipasti and pizza choices at Montesacro were a fresh change. Beautiful crust and topping on the pizza and refreshing antipasti. Enjoy the garden!

Very good Italian food in a cool atmosphere Amazing Carbonara, Raviolis and superb Pinsas Good Negronis, as well Perfect

We went for brunch and wanted to stay for dinner. It was just that good. They do a wonderful fresh, modern twist on Roman food. The eggs Benedict w prosciutto, burrata and roasted tomatoes was out of this world. Their back garden is open year round and very comfortable. The coffee drinkers said it was their best cup the entire trip.

This place is such a treat. Great wine/cocktails and recommendations for pairing. Pinsa is so light and fluffy, it’s ‘reduced guilt’ pizza but elevated. Their glass garden is open year round which creates such a jungle vibe - with all its plants. Temperature in the back is perfect. What a gem!

Superb italian Pinsa (which Is Little different from Classic pizza BUT DO TRY IT). We Just loved the place ( OMG THE GARDEN!) the food and the people. Will go back for sure when in NY. Bravo Luca! Continua cosi! Belive us, WE'RE ITALIAN!!

Everything about this place was perfect - from the atmosphere of the back room to the variety of menu options to the food to the service - we just loved it at Montesacro. Emanuele, the owner/manager, could not have been more responsive and helpful. The food was delicious and abundant and the venue (we had the entire back room) was beautiful with a warm and urban ambiance. It was amazing having a retractable roof on a nice night. I highly recommend Montesacro if you're looking for a restaurant for a special event.

Really special place in a fantastic city. Delicious food with flavors that take you to Italy. Friendliness and hospitality are the highlight. The owner Emanuele is really a special person and his particularity is sensitivity. Highly recommended.

Let’s talk about the super delicious pinsa. My mom and me loved it. The service, the location and the food were georgous. Will come back for sure

Stumbled on to this place while staying at the new hotel indigo Williamsburg. Great Pinsas (really pizzas) with very high quality toppings. Nice bar and small indoor seating area - large outside area - covered and heated when needed

I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone. My Italian wife has pretty high standards for Italian food outside of Italy but this place delivers. On top of that they make you feel very welcome and deliver great service. I don't think you could order anything bad on the menu.

This place is awesome. I can’t recommend it highly enough. The food is great, the drinks are great, the weight staff is excellent and attentive. The prices are quite reasonable for the flavor value.

They put us on the terrace and despite The noise from the rest of the diners (then they say from the Spanish) was very pleasant. Very delicious pasta: well cooked and authentic sauces. The portions are small and at a high price (Brooklyn) except for the pizzas, which are a good size. All very rich.

Absolutely exquisite pizza in NY. Great open air area. Nice drinks and perfect food. They call it pinsa instead of pizza because of its shape but it is delicious pizza.

Made reservation on OpenTable for a special occasion and even stopped by two nights beforehand to see if there was any way to reserve a specific table for our group. Unfortunately, the server working at the time wasn’t welcoming, wouldn’t take my name, and just told me it wasn’t possible - it would be first come, first served even with a reservation. On the actual night, I arrived 45 minutes early, and the host who greeted me at the door was also not warm or friendly. I felt like I was being a bother just by asking 2 questions. For such a special occasion, it was disappointing that the table offered to us was right by the entrance. When I politely asked to move more toward the back, the host seemed annoyed. Thankfully, once we were seated, everything turned around. Our server was absolutely fantastic - warm, attentive, and made us feel truly cared for. The food was also incredible! We had drinks at bar after and the bartender was not welcoming either. This restaurant has so much going for it, but a little more warmth and hospitality at the front would go a long way in making the full experience match the quality of the kitchen and restaurant service team.

Great food and service! Would definitely come again. I have a TBI and they graciously lowered the music in the front area so that I could dine in comfort.

We were there during lunchtime on a Monday and they weren’t many people. We sat outside and it was pretty good even though they were constructions site close by. Food was good - price was reasonable.

We stayed for two nights for dinner in this place, the first night at a table near the entrance while the second night in the back room which is a show. The supplì very good perhaps better than other places here in Italy and good also pinsa. Great desserts definitely recommend it.

Cute local Italian products on pinse as in the excellent pasta. Light and really well done mixed fried Absolutely worth trying , it's really worth it Excellent tiramisu!