Nino's Pizza Reviews

This is by the far the best Pizza place in Bay Ridge. Hands down. Their Grandmama slice is too good. It is so good, you can’t have just one. Their plain is just the right level of cheesy and crispy. Highly recommend!!

Just go and taste as many slices as you can! I love Grandma and Beringela's, my husband ate the pepperoni and cheese. there tb has perfect pasta. all with fresh ingredients and leaving the RJ pizza on the omg floor.

Don't miss getting a pizza here if you if you can help it. It will be delicious! A large variety of ingredients and the talented staff will make your visit well worthwhile.

Nino's Pizza is a Bay Ridge treasure. It's just a casual neighborhood pizza place, but we locals love it for the variety of specialty pizzas--the deep-dish eggplant is my fave. They're not cheap, but worth it. The crust and sauces are homemade. Delivery is fast and reliable or eat in at little tables.

damn good slices. thin, crispy, hot, fresh. well deserving of 5 stars. prices are good and service is fast.

First thing you shuld know - during the big blackout of 2002 (2003?), Nino's immediately began to give their food away. They knew that there were no refridgerators/freezers, no power to salvage their supplies, and while other Brooklyn businesses were locking their gates and business owners were stationed in front of their stores (some of them with guns visible) to deter any looting or vandalism, Nino's was going full-steam until the wee hours of the morning, giving food away and allowing people to converge in front of the store, talk, share, laugh & relax in a post-9/11 NYC. That speaks VOLUMES about a business and its owners. And the food is GREAT!!! Try the vodka pie & Grandmama's - the best in Bay Ridge, possibly in Brooklyn. I am moving in six days, have packed my entire kitchen already, and will be ordering Nino's at least three more times before I go, just to say goodbye to a local neighborhood pizzeria that's taken care of me for eight years. THANKS NINO'S!

Go to takeout spot. Their grandma pizza is awesome and they make a great brooklyn round slice. The food is always hot and fresh and they have an extensive red sauce Italian menu.

Best pizza I’ve had in quite a while. Owner super friendly, gave a little background on his family and the restaurant. Definitely nothing like it in Texas.

My favorite pizza in Brooklyn.

Fantastic pizza! Service very good and reliable. Pizza is the best! Garlic knots great. Fast service, friendly. Great pizza makers!

Usually when I want pizza, I go for a classic NY slice. For some reason yesterday I was craving a neopolitan pie. I couldn’t find any pizza places that baked neopolitan pies with walking distance or on seamless. After much searching I found this place. I knew it wouldn’t be exactly what I was craving, but figured it would be close enough. At that point even a good NY slice would’ve sufficed. Upon tasting a slice, I was quite surprised. I’d say this pizza is neither here nor there. It’s not a good NY slice, it’s not neopolitan, it’s not pretend pizza (aka Dominos and Papa Johns), it’s not even bad neopolitan. It’s unlike any other pizza I’ve ever had, and not in a good way. The dough was very stiff, there was no chew or stretch to it. The fresh mozzarella and sauce were fine, but the dough made eating the pizza unappealing. This was the first time I’ve ever had trouble biting into a slice, the dough was that unforgiving. Knife and fork pizza! We also ordered garlic knots. On the plus side, they were large, soft and very garlicky. They were also soaked in oil though, way above what is normal. The saving grace of the order was the chicken Parmesan garlic knot. It’s a great idea, tasted delicious, and was well executed, except for once again, the garlic knot was incredibly oily.

What I love about this place is that it is very consistent over the years the food has remained very good the quality has stayed the same. I love ordering their grandmas pizza it’s a crunchy thin crust with tomatoes and extra virgin olive oil drizzled on top. You can’t go wrong with anything on their menu they make the best garlic knots they also make delicious chicken Parmesan baked ziti etc.

My family and I recently travelled to Italy and the pizza at Ninos in Bayridge is better. Not only is the pizza the greatest in the world but the guys at Ninos are the nicest people on the planet!!! If you are in bayridge go to Ninos for a slice or two or three....You'll be so glad you did!!!

I love this pizzeria. Their Grandma slice is beyond compare. I always want to come here when I visit my daughter. I also love their potato croquettes. This is something that you just don't find everywhere. Nino's is my favorite pizzeria in Brooklyn.

Hands down the best pizza place in Brooklyn and probably in New York. Same quality and taste for the last 15 years. Ask for gran mama and vodka pizzas by the slice. Great prices and service in the best neighborhood of Brooklyn.

I came here looking for the NY pizza experience. You know, the big cheese or pepperoni slice that you have to fold in half that is an icon of the NYC night life. Well, this isn’t quite it but the pizza was pretty good. Nice sauce and a decent size for 3.25. Didn’t quite give me the experience but was still well baked pizza. They prefer cash.

Best pizza in Brooklyn second only to Spumoni Gardens. Great staff, all their pizza is so fresh and good. Added plus is they actually have spumoni gardens ices in the summer. Not to be missed!

Beside just pizza , they have amazing Italian dinners as well ! I prefer the Calzones and Stromboli's which are full of prosciutto ! Great place to relax at and eat well !

Give it a try you wont be disappointed. Not the best pizza in the world:) But its worth trying for sure.

Best pizza. Favorite spot in bay ridge and possibly all of brooklyn. Great variety. Tasty concoctions. Traditional meets modern

Nino's Pizza is a truly exceptional restaurant. Their pizza is juicy, crispy, and pure New York. Their grandmamma pizza is especially famous. It's perfect for a tasty lunch, but the restaurant is small, so I wouldn't reccomend it for a fancy dinner.

Great New York pizza! Just stopped in out of the blue and had a great pie. Small place, not much room. But great staff and awesome food.

Decided to come to this place while checking out Bay Ridge. Love this neighborhood. The pizza is truely one of a kind. Aside from the being the best grandma I ever tried. They also have great Sicilian, Margarita, and Sofia Loren Pizza. You can tell they put love into their products. It's not to be missed!!

This pizzeria is very good. The grandma is always fresh and delicious, but my favorite is the "Sophia Loren" (mozzarella, tomatoes and garlic), especially when they just made it. Definitely worth a visit, if you're hungry and in the BayRidge/Ft Hamilton area. Not really a destination, though, IMO.

Had the Greek salad pizza slice and was thrilled. The sausage roll was ok but the crust wasn't thick enough. Over all decent MY pizza.

Best Grandma in Brooklyn. Good heros too.

Nino's has the most amazing pizza in Bay Ridge. In fact, its pizza is one of the BEST in all of NYC!! I would say it's just as good as Spumoni Gardens. Their sauce is delicious and that's what makes a good pizza or excellent pasta. Their grandma pizza is to die for!! I highly recommend their food. I've tasted pizza in many places, including Italy & if you want to have fantastic pizza in NYC, this is definitely the place to have it at!! I always buy their pizza, wrap it in aluminum foil & take it to my siblings in Miami...they swear there's nothing like Nino's pizza & I can definitely attest to that!!!

Nino's has excellent thin crust NYC style pizza, but their real specialties are the Grandma pizza and Sicilian pizza--some of the best examples of those types of pizza in NYC. This restaurant is easy to get to via subway and is worth a trip from Manhattan.

I was told the Grandma's slice was the pizza to have. It did not disappoint. It was full of flavor. I loved the brick oven crust. The staff was friendly and helpful. Great price. 2 slices for $5.00

Nino's offers great pizzas, although a bit pricey. My favorite is their specialty Margarita Pizza. Not greasy and melts in your mouth!

Stop by Ninos for a late snack; their Granma pizza is still the best in Bayridge. So is thei pasta dishes.

Stole a slice of margerita pizza from my wife’s pie while in Bayridge. Liked the sauce a lot. Very tasty and light pizza. Would go back.

OMG the best pizza ever period! From the classic slice to their trademark grand-mama (thin crust square mmmmmmm good) you cant go wrong and what an array of high quality choices from the vodka slice (no it dosnt contain real vodka) to the margarita slice (no real margaritas either ;p) every thing is amazing - and they don't stop their try ordering something from the kitchen you might smack your wife (or your self if your the wife) for not cooking as well, you'd think there was an old Italian lady in the back cooking (there aint i checked- but it seems some took her cook book and made her disappear) I'm telling you for an authentic Brooklyn pizza and italian food this is the place to go to! or have it delivered as long as your staying in a Bay Ridge hotel like i did (save money- and only 20 min to city) this is the place to get the real brooklyn feel and taste Chow!!

Authentic Italian pizza!! Everything is tasty, that makes you want to come back to grab another slice!! If you are in Bayridge you can't miss!

Your neighborhood Pizzeria with several versions of Pizza and their toppings. Also take out menu of Italian Dishes and Pasta Plates.. They do have delivery service and of course you can eat in the restaurant also.