Osteria Brooklyn Reviews

Honestly probably one of my top favorite authentic Italian restaurants. I was mind blown with the fettuccine osteria the first time i had it (literally went back a week later) so flavorful and i love that they cook it right in front of you. Everything was delicious. The dessert menu is amazing they have all desserts at display. The place super cute and chill. Everyone was very attentive service was great. 10/10 💖

What a treasure! We felt welcomed the moment we stepped in the lovely space. The food was divine and the service was just what we love, relaxed yet attentive. It was a superb neighborhood bistro and I’m so happy we found it. You will not be disappointed.

Poor service. Mediocre food. Think chef owner changed or not involved any more. Changes notable from our last time and not for the better

Food just okay, wait staff decent, chef/owner somewhat brusque. Located on Myrtle Ave. it is probably the best of the area, but would think twice about another visit.

On a nice chilly and sunny day-off, to commute for an hour and a half, for best traditional Italian flavors…colors, presentation, warm welcome, friendly service by server Andres…I hit the Bulls eye…Osteria B’klyn‼️ loved every bite of all 3 courses ala carte decadent dishes. Kudos to Chef’s concoctions…😋❣️ 👍👌‼️

This was one of the best meals I've ever had in my life!!! I ordered the fettucine osteria which they prepare in front of you using a cheese wheel! It's a cozy restaurant with excellent service! We also loved the crème brulee! We were so glad we had this recommended as everyone in our group said it was one of the best meals we had in NYC!

This is a very nice Italo- American restaurant on Myrtle Avenue. In terms of upmarket restaurants there is not a lot of competition in this area. Osteria Brooklyn makes up for that by providing good food, a very pleasant decor, plus efficient and even enthusiastic service. I shall return!

I've had mixed experiences at osteria brooklyn. Some consistent things are: 1) seems expensive, but it's actually reasonable pricing for homemade food at a fancy restaurant in NYC. 2) small portion sizes, but we are in Brooklyn after all. 3) love the scenery and fun, colorful vibe of the outdoor dining. Both outside and inside the restaurant are beautiful! I've tried the mushroom risotto, pesto gnocchi, and margherita pizza here. All are great! The gnocchi I really loved - tasted very fresh! So you might be wondering why I said my experiences were mixed. Well, the first time I came here, the bread AND dipping oil were AMAZING! I was telling my friends all about it, so imagine what a FOOL I felt when we never got any bread! Or dipping oil, for that matter! The third time, I was really excited because I saw we actually got bread, but it was this hard, sweet, experimental type of bread that nobody liked. Not just that it wasn't our taste - it was actually bad. Plus, very mixed experiences with service. The woman with the dark hair who lived on Clinton Hill is so sweet and friendly, but beware of the blonde woman.

Best italian food you can ask for! I met the chef when he was working at another restaurant, and when we went there and found out he wasn’t working there anymore, I looked for him on social media and found him! Since that moment, we only go to Osteria Brooklyn, and we have been there many tines. Everytime we have visitors we take them there and they love it! Food is amazing but the burrata with prosciutto & fig is just unreal!! And also fetuccine osteria is another must. They also have dessert on display and they bring it to your table so you can see how desserts look like.

Best Italian food we ever had. Cosy little place in beautiful Brooklyn. Great waiters. Definitely get the special fettuccine prepared by the table with cheese on fire! We will definitely be back another time!

Restaurant has an Italian Family feel. Nice variety of fresh homemade pasta dishes. Our friend said best chicken parm she has ever had. Great homemade desserts too.

incredible food. Came here for the first time. Can’t recommend any higher. Great vide, drinks and incredible food. Pizza and past was unbelievable. You must come here.