Pizza Secret Reviews

Definitely the best Neapolitan pizza that Brooklyn has to offer. I had a great experience: awesome food, kind service in an overall pleasant setting. I'll return soon!

We ordered an appetizer. I ordered a pasta entree and my husband ordered a pizza. The past arrived. No appetizer. After 20 minutes still no pizza. I started to eat because my pasta was getting cold. No pizza ever arrived. The waitress seemed genuinely apologetic. My husband had to go get Chinese takeout after. Such a shame. We've eaten there before and the pizza is quite good. We probably won't go back.

This pizzeria was recommended by a friend from Naples to be one of the best in NY and it really is. The wine list is not huge but they have a really good Prosecco and other good wines for affordable prices. I will come back every time I’m in NY. The service was very friendly.

We had 2 pizzas, style of Napoli with the edge a bit thicker. Each had a little surprise (which we could have known reading the menu properly): the Americana was a little sweet (ouch) and the Viola&pancetta had no tomato (which was acceptable:-)). Good taste, perhaps needed a few seconds longer in the oven. Cozy setting, we liked it.

The restaurant has a great location on 5th Ave in Brooklyn. The store overall looks stylish, tidy but still traditional. The external impression conveys the food experience fairly exactly. The dishes are authentic, rustic and at the same time adapted and served in a modern way. My pizza tasted like a good Italian pizzeria, but even better. What kind of taste is that? Lemongrass? I didn't expect that and certainly not that it could fit so well...

OMG, stumbling upon this restaurant was the PERFECT end to a great trip. So authentic, from the people and ambiance to the menu and quality of food- this was nothing short of amazing. We indulged in the Caprese di Burrata, Polpette Napoletane (meatballs) and Parmigiana al Forno (eggplant). You feel love and family in this place. The chef surprised us with the Panna Cotta and Nutella to end on a sweet note. ❤️ I wish I could take it all back to Florida with me!

Excellent service, tgr atmosphere was electric and inviting. The food was delicious, I got some prosciutto and a margherita pizza. I have not been to Italy, but I would think this would be a good sample of what i could expect.

Good selection of different pizzas, great happy hour offer, the glasses are big! Nice location and atmosphere. I would be back

Ugg . I ordered online for delivery to a hotel I was staying at . In the order form , I put a note to let me know when they were close and I would meet them in the lobby . Instead , they sent a text saying my delivery was in the lobby . I went down right away , and saw my food laying unattended on a table in w busy lobby . The delivery person just left it there . I got the pizza to my room . It was cold and soggy . Yuck Not a great experience at all

Second time ordering pizza here. Quick and very friendly service. Excellent pizza. Very authentic, like what you’d get in Italy. Interesting toppings.

Food - provola and pepe pizza goes down as one of the best I've eaten. Could even be the best! The trofie was a bit too aldente for our liking, but good pesto. Drink - Bee's Knees, first prep was too sour, second perfectly balanced. I was expecting a pretty little glass, this was served in tall highball one. Dessert - the chocolate lava cake, didn't impress. It was frozen to thawed and not flowing properly. On bringing that up - it almost seemed like they took that plate, microwaved and brought it back - even the cream was flowing this time :p Service - top notch and extremely friendly. Simple, rustic, clean decor.

I live above this establishment and have eaten there one time. I'll start with my food review. It was ok but nothing special. There is a pizza place on the same block (Nate's) that is much better in my opinion for half the price. The wine was pretty good at Pizza Secret though. On a different note, I have been complaining about their noise levels for months (including 311 complaints). They have speakers in their ceiling that I can clearly hear in my apartment and the bass on them constantly vibrates my floor. Despite trying to cooperate with them politely countless times they have not improved. They will not adjust their bass whatsoever. At one point the owner Rosario aggressively told me to come downstairs, another time he insinuated that he could play music as loudly as he wants because he "pays $50,000 in rent". The noise begins when I'm working and carries past quiet hours daily. 10+ hours per day on average. I suggest going elsewhere because this establishment is run by an owner that does not seem to feel genuine care or empathy towards his neighboring community. I have lots of videos of this behavior but unfortunately I can’t past videos here. Thank you for reading!

In town for work. Table for one. I had an excellent experience. The pizza was very good. Had an arugula salad and broccoli rabe side. Broccoli rabe was outstanding. The best part of the experience was the service. The waiter was a young man from Napoli. He spent extra time talking with me about italy and soccer. An overall very authentic experience. I will be back.

It is a really Nice restaurant with a very friendly owner, he is from napoly, italy, so he really knows how to make delicious pizza’s. Also the salads are really Nice! This is certainly a restaurant where i would come back!!! It is also really good price/quality!

Went two days ago in this cozy restaurant. The owner, Rosario is from Napoli (my hometown) he makes the pizza napoletana the way it's supposed to be. I'd suggest this spot also for a romantic date!

Pizza Secret is the place to go for eating very good Italian dishes in NYC! Un incredible choice in the menu, the excellent ingredients and the creativity of Rosario's pizzas make the difference! Pizza Secret is the authentic Neapolitan pizzeria in the lovely Brooklyn!

Was ecstatic to finally find a place that makes a pizza just like Napoli. If you ever had a pizza in Naples Italy and loved it, then you have to go to Pizza Secret. A++ delizioso

The place is nearby the Barclays Centre and easily reachable by the subway The pizza is a good neapolitan pizzeria and the prices are quite covenients respect the quality I went there with a girlfriend for dinner and had a nice experience Highly recommended!

I really don’t like leaving bad reviews, but we tried pizza from here again, and the “secret” really is no one there knows how to make a good pizza. It is literally the worst pizza we have ever had; limp, mushy, wet, tasteless with gummy dough. They have a great little wood burning oven but don’t know how to cook in it. I so wish they did, and I am baffled by the good reviews of their pizza. In the past, we tried the meatballs, which were OK, and maybe some other things are good. but stay away from the pizza unless you like sauce on ordinary white bread. It’s sad.

We had the best time at Pizza Secret! Our kids enjoyed not only playing with dough but eating the incredibly delicious pizza. The wine was excellent, fantastic atmosphere, and we can't wait to return.

Had a wonderful dinner at this place. Service great, food was delicious and great atmosphere. Will definetly go there again!