Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant Reviews

This pizzeria is located in my old neighborhood Bushwick Brooklyn . I've been coming here for about 40 years . Excellent pizza and service highly recommend it .

The food at TONYS PIZZA is consistently excellent, particularly the diverse selection of pizzas. However, the one downside for me is the switch to mini pepperonis instead of the original large ones—I’d much rather have the classic version. Aside from that, it’s absolutely fantastic!

New York pizza is of a unique taste. It is not at all the same as other places in the world. Tony's Pizzeria captures this unique and wonderful taste and serves it still as good as when I grew up in the neighbourhood 20+ years ago. On my visit home I told my sister how sometimes I would get in the mood for NY pizza back home (London) but since visiting I had not had one. Immediately she got on the horn and order a magnificent pie that I had 3 slices over the day. NY pizza taste is different and although other global pizzas are great also, my tummy and heart remain tomatofied by this little gem.

We shared a classic Margherita and a pepperoni pie, both bursting with flavor. The crust was perfectly crispy, and the cheese melted in our mouths. The cozy atmosphere made it feel like home. We can't wait to return and explore more of their menu—Tony's is now our go-to spot in Brooklyn!

I have tried all of the big names in pizza in NYC and can safely say that Tony's Pizzeria is easily the best of all of them! The staff are so friendly and helpful and make customers feel like part of their family. To add to the NY atmosphere, Sopranos was playing on the TV in the background while we ate our pizza. Cannot recommend this place enough.

I'm always on the hunt for a great NY slice. Seems to be harder and harder to find the thin, crispy, flavorful slices I dream about. Tony's hits the mark. Thin and crispy, flavorful sauce and toppings. It's an old-school, real-deal kind of place. Recommend the upside down, grandma, white, and all the rest.

The best in customer service, I have the best calzone ever,from meaty pizza, chicken salad and vegetarian pizza in a group of 9 people,from pre teenagers to a senior everyone was happy with their food,we had a great time, we were treated so good, best combination, good food, good service, good time

I placed an order for delivery and when the food arrived it was ice cold. A 50 minute delivery took an hour and 20 minutes. Will never order from Tony’s again. Will never recommend them either.

I came across Tony’s because they paid a visit to my job to introduce themselves. Little did I know this gem was so close to home and work. We started with a small business order and ordered 3x after that. Jack was my contact. I finally paid them a visit with my family and we all loved it. The service was incredible and so was the food. Will be going back and/or ordering from here often.

I was staying with a group of my students (from Canada), and wanted to introduce them to real Brooklyn pizza. Tony's did not disappoint at all. Great pizza at a good price. Highly recommended.

I stumbled upon this pizzeria by accident last year and was blown away by their regular cheese slice and mosty their Sicilian (I am not a big pizza eater and only eat meat free pizza). As I was in town this week I could not wait to go back and devour another sicilian. The taste, the sauce, the texture were flawless, (it has nothing to do with some touristy Manhattan sicilians). I took a slice home to eat the next day; after warming in the oven (not microwave), it was even better. The staff there is busy but professional and nice. Authentic NY pizza taste from my childhood.

If you want a really great pizza this the place to have a slice. The pizza sauce has a really distinct taste and is really delicious.