Provincetown Inn or pilgrim house

Question

Hello - advice needed. I can't decide if we should book a cape tip room at Provincetown Inn or the Pilgrim House 2 bedroom suite. I appreciate the more quiet aspects of Provincetown Inn however I am reading that it is run down. Advice?

Answer

Choosing between Provincetown Inn and Pilgrim House depends on what you value most: quiet, location, and room quality versus amenities and updated accommodations.

Provincetown Inn:

Pros: Known for a quieter, more secluded feel, away from the busiest downtown streets. It’s ideal if you prefer a peaceful environment and easy access to nature or the beaches.
Cons: Some reviews indicate that the property is somewhat run-down, with older furnishings and décor. Depending on the room, amenities may be basic, and maintenance can be inconsistent.
Best for: Couples or small groups looking for a relaxed, less crowded stay with a quieter vibe.

Pilgrim House 2-Bedroom Suite:

Pros: Central location in Provincetown, easy walking distance to shops, restaurants, and nightlife. Suites tend to be more modern, with updated bathrooms and kitchen facilities, ideal for families or groups needing extra space.
Cons: Being downtown means it can be noisier, especially during peak tourist season or evenings. Less of a “retreat” feel compared to Provincetown Inn.
Best for: Families or groups who want to be in the heart of Provincetown with convenient access to activities and a fully equipped suite.

Considerations:

If peace and a quieter location are more important than modern amenities, Provincetown Inn is a good choice, but prepare for potentially older facilities.
If you prioritize comfort, updated interiors, and being within walking distance of downtown attractions, Pilgrim House offers a better overall experience.
Check recent reviews on both properties for updates on cleanliness, maintenance, and noise levels to ensure your expectations match the current conditions.

Ultimately, it comes down to whether you prefer a tranquil, “off-the-beaten-path” stay or a more central, convenient location with modern accommodations. For a first-time trip where access to shops, restaurants, and the buzz of Provincetown is appealing, the Pilgrim House suite may offer a more comfortable and reliable experience. If you’re returning for a relaxing getaway and don’t mind older furnishings, Provincetown Inn could suit your needs.

Provincetown Inn or pilgrim house

More Provincetown Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions