Princeville or Hanalei?

Question

We'll be on Kauai for six days late September. Which of these two towns would you prefer, and why? BTW, we'll rent an Airbnb or VRBO rather than an overpriced hotel.

TIA

Answer

Both Princeville and Hanalei are beautiful towns on Kauai’s North Shore, but they offer slightly different experiences. Choosing between them depends on what kind of vibe and convenience you’re looking for during your six-day stay.

Princeville:

More resort-oriented, with several upscale communities and vacation rentals that often have stunning ocean or golf course views.
Quieter and more residential feel, less of a “town” atmosphere but very scenic and peaceful.
Good base for exploring the North Shore without the crowds; many rental properties here are perched on cliffs overlooking the ocean or bays.
Close to beaches like Hanalei Bay and Anini Beach, but may require a short drive to access restaurants and shops.

Hanalei:

Charming, small-town feel with a lively main street, local shops, art galleries, and casual restaurants.
Closer access to Hanalei Bay for swimming, paddleboarding, and relaxing on the beach.
More walkable town center, making it convenient for picking up groceries or enjoying casual dining without a car.
Slightly more bustling vibe than Princeville, with more tourists around the main street area but still very relaxed compared to other parts of Hawaii.

Recommendation:

If you prioritize a peaceful, scenic stay with more secluded vacation rentals and ocean views, Princeville is the better choice.
If you want to be in the heart of a charming town with easy access to shops, restaurants, and beach activities, Hanalei is ideal.
Given that you’re renting an Airbnb or VRBO, either town offers excellent rental options, but the choice largely comes down to whether you want a more residential, resort-style base (Princeville) or a town-centered, beach-accessible experience (Hanalei).

Both towns are close enough that you can easily explore each during your stay, so even if you pick one as your home base, you won’t miss out on the highlights of the other.

Princeville or Hanalei?

More Hawaii (HI) Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions