Fat Clemenza’s

Question

Making a reservation for Fat Clemenza’s and it asks where we want to reserve. The square or the rectangle. Which is better

Answer

Good question — I couldn’t find any reliable public information (websites, reviews, or menus) that describes a “square” vs. “rectangle” dining room or seating area at Fat Clemenza’s in Miramar Beach. Their official site and other sources don't mention this distinction. That said, based on what *is* known about the restaurant and how to decide on seating, here are some thoughts and practical advice.

What We Know About Fat Clemenza’s Seating & Atmosphere

Fat Clemenza’s is a cozy Italian restaurant / pizzeria with both indoor and outdoor seating.
The restaurant has a “warm and inviting” atmosphere, with a friendly, family-oriented vibe.
BringFido notes that there are dog-friendly outdoor tables, meaning some seating is outside.
According to reviews on Tripadvisor, the space is “smaller,” which may limit how many large tables you can have indoors.

Why the Reservation System Might Ask “Square” vs. “Rectangle”

Since there’s no public diagram or clear description, there are a few possibilities for what “square” vs. “rectangle” could mean in their reservation system:

It could refer to different sections or layouts inside — perhaps one room has square tables, or a square-shaped dining area, and another is more rectangular.
It might denote table shapes — e.g., square tables (maybe better for smaller, more intimate groups) vs. long rectangular tables (better for larger parties or families).
It could be an internal reservation designation that helps the staff plan for table setup, traffic flow, or how many people can be seated together.

How to Decide Which to Pick

Without clear public guidance, your best bet is to pick based on your party size, how social you want to be, and your preference for more privacy or a lively feel:

If your group is large (say, 6–10 or more), the rectangular option might make sense — rectangular tables often accommodate more people in a row.
If it’s a smaller group or you prefer a more intimate dining experience, the square option (if it means either square tables or a squared-off section) could feel cozier.
If you want outdoor seating (especially if you’re bringing a dog), you could mention this when making the reservation — even if “square” vs. “rectangle” doesn’t map directly to indoor vs. outdoor, the staff might be able to place you where you'd like.
When you call to make the reservation, you can ask for clarification: “What do you mean by square vs. rectangle seating?” and specify what would work best for your group.

My Recommendation

Because the distinction isn’t well explained publicly, I lean toward choosing rectangle if you’re booking for a moderately large group or want longer tables. But if you’re okay with a more relaxed setup and want a cozier feel, square is likely fine. Most importantly, call the restaurant when booking — they should be happy to help you choose the best section for your party and clarify exactly what those terms mean in their layout.

Bottom line: Neither option seems inherently “better” in terms of food or service, so base your choice on your group size and seating preferences. Asking when you call will probably give you exactly the right arrangement.

Fat Clemenza’s

More Miramar Beach Travel Questions

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions