Forgotten Shores Property Management Group

Question

Wondering if anyone has used this company for rentals on St George Island ? TIA

Answer

Great question. Yes — Forgotten Shores Property Management Group (also referred to as Forgotten Shores Properties) is a well-established, local vacation rental company on St. George Island and Eastpoint, FL. Here’s a breakdown of what they are like, plus what to watch out for, based on publicly available info:

What the company is and how it operates:

They are family-owned and have been managing rentals for more than 10 years.
Their team is “local, only a few minutes from St. George Island,” so they provide 24/7 guest support for maintenance issues, questions, or local recommendations.
They manage a wide range of property types: from cozy beach cottages to multi-story beachfront homes.
Many of their rentals are pet friendly and include amenities such as private pools, hot tubs, and even elevators.

Positives / Strengths:

Because they’re smaller and local, they tend to offer personalized service. Forgotten Shores states they treat renters like “welcome guests” and give homeowners attention that large management companies can’t.
Their local presence means they really know the area — great for guest recommendations on things to do or places to eat.
Their experience in maintenance and housekeeping (they say their staff has held many roles over the years) suggests solid operations and guest care.

Considerations / Potential Drawbacks:

Because they manage many types of homes, quality may vary: some homes are older cottages, others are luxury beachfront properties. Read individual property reviews carefully.
On one VRBO listing handled by Forgotten Shores, a guest mentioned that the home was “very outdated” and had electrical and AC issues — but also said Forgotten Shores responded and resolved the problems.
As with any vacation rental manager, availability during peak season might be limited, so book early.

Overall Impression:

Forgotten Shores Property Management is generally respectable and reliable, especially for St. George Island rentals. Their local roots, 24/7 support, and broad property portfolio make them a strong choice if you’re looking to stay in that area. For peace of mind, when you pick a specific rental, check: