Help deciding where to stay in Keys

Question

Hi. Solo female traveler in need of help planning a last minute trip for 4 nights within the next two weeks. Budget about 350 per night. Looking for a nice and safe place to stay in the Keys. Priority on beaches, sunsets and good food. Don't want to rent a car but will if I have to. Big plus for a place with a tub in the room. Appreciate the help. I was planning to go back to the Carribean but places start closing for hurricane season. Thanks in advance.

Answer

For a solo female traveler looking for a relaxing and safe spot in the Florida Keys, you have several great options, especially given your preference for beaches, sunsets, good food, and a comfortable room with a tub. Since you're aiming for a budget of about $350 per night, there are plenty of places that offer a mix of these amenities without needing to rent a car (though it can still be useful for getting around in some cases). Here are a few recommendations based on your priorities:

1. Key West: If you're open to staying in Key West, it's the most walkable destination in the Keys with plenty of beaches, dining options, and activities right at your doorstep. While it’s a bit pricier than other parts of the Keys, you can still find places that fit your budget.

The Gates Hotel Key West: A stylish, boutique hotel with a relaxed vibe. The hotel offers a great pool area, nice rooms with modern amenities, and it's only a short ride to the beach and local attractions. Many rooms feature a soaking tub. It’s a safe and walkable area, and you’ll have no trouble finding nearby places to eat and shop.
Heron House: A cozy and intimate guesthouse in Old Town Key West, known for its peaceful setting and beautiful gardens. It offers a great location close to everything (including Sunset Pier, which is ideal for watching sunsets) and is within walking distance of many local restaurants. Some rooms have bathtubs, and the overall ambiance is relaxed and safe.
Southernmost Beach Resort: Located on the quieter side of the island, this resort has direct access to the beach, great for a relaxing day in the sun. You’ll be able to walk to nearby attractions and restaurants. Rooms with tubs are available, and you can enjoy the resort’s amenities without needing a car.

2. Marathon (Middle Keys): Marathon offers a more relaxed, less crowded atmosphere compared to Key West but still offers beautiful beaches and great dining options. It’s also a little more affordable and can be more budget-friendly.

Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort: This resort is a perfect place to unwind, with beautiful beach access, spacious rooms, and a laid-back atmosphere. While it’s on the higher end of your budget, it offers a lovely beachfront experience with great amenities, including rooms with soaking tubs. It’s not as walkable as Key West, but you can easily get around with taxis or rideshare services.
Fairfield Inn & Suites by Marriott Marathon Key: A more affordable option with a pool, beach access, and clean, modern rooms. It’s a comfortable, safe spot to stay, with great access to food and shopping. It might not have the same high-end feel as some other resorts, but it’s very solid and meets your needs for a short stay.

3. Islamorada (Upper Keys): Islamorada is another peaceful, scenic area that’s known for its stunning sunsets, beaches, and seafood. It’s less bustling than Key West but still offers some great spots for a relaxing getaway.

Amara Cay Resort: This is a great mid-range option, with beach access, a beautiful pool, and some rooms featuring soaking tubs. The resort offers a relaxed atmosphere with excellent food and drink options right on-site, and you’ll be able to walk to nearby restaurants or bars. It’s a bit more tranquil than Key West and offers great sunset views.
Cheeca Lodge & Spa: This iconic resort offers a luxurious stay with an amazing beachfront location. It’s a bit pricier, but you may be able to find a room within your budget depending on deals. It has everything: a beautiful beach, an excellent restaurant, and amenities that cater to both relaxation and adventure. Rooms with tubs are available.

Food and Sunset Views: All of these locations have fantastic food and sunset views. For dining, you’ll find many seafood restaurants along the Keys, including Blue Heaven (Key West), Lazy Days (Islamorada), and The Fish House (Marathon), all offering fresh, local dishes. Key West is particularly well-known for its sunset views from spots like Sunset Pier and Mallory Square, while Marathon and Islamorada also offer great vantage points along their waterfronts.

Summary of Recommendations:

If you're looking for vibrant nightlife, walkability, and easy beach access, Key West is the top choice. Look for places like The Gates Hotel or Heron House for a more intimate and safe stay.
If you prefer a quieter, more affordable option with beach access and a laid-back vibe, Marathon (e.g., Tranquility Bay Beachfront Resort) offers the best of both worlds.
If you're seeking a more tranquil, scenic experience with stunning sunsets, Islamorada (e.g., Amara Cay Resort) could be ideal.

All of these areas are safe and offer easy access to great food, beaches, and sunsets, with no need to rent a car unless you're planning to explore further into the Keys. Enjoy your trip, and feel free to reach out if you need more details!