Caesar Salad

Question

Where are some of your favorite restaurants for a Caesar Salad? In my experience it can vary quite a bit.

Answer

Key West offers a wide range of dining options, and a good Caesar salad can vary greatly depending on whether the restaurant focuses on fresh ingredients, house-made dressing, or presentation. Here are some popular spots where locals and visitors consistently praise the quality of their Caesar salads.

Restaurants Known for Great Caesar Salads:

Blue Heaven: Famous for its laid-back atmosphere and fresh ingredients. Their Caesar salad is made with crisp romaine, house-made dressing, and topped with crunchy croutons, perfect for a light lunch or starter.
Louie’s Backyard: Upscale dining with ocean views. Their Caesar salad is elegantly prepared, often with shaved Parmesan, anchovies on request, and fresh homemade croutons. Excellent for a refined dining experience.
Alonzo’s Oyster Bar: Casual waterfront spot. While known for seafood, their Caesar salad is fresh, well-dressed, and pairs beautifully with their oysters or fish tacos.
Hogfish Bar & Grill: Off-the-beaten-path on Stock Island. Their Caesar salad is fresh, simple, and hearty, making it a great accompaniment to their signature hogfish sandwich.

Tips for Enjoying a Caesar Salad in Key West:

Ask if the dressing is house-made; many restaurants have their own secret recipes, which can dramatically change the flavor profile.
Check if anchovies are included or optional—classic Caesar traditionally has them, but not all restaurants follow this.
Consider pairing the salad with seafood for a true Key West experience, as many local restaurants focus on fresh fish and shellfish that complement the salad.

Whether you’re after a casual bite or a fine dining experience, Key West has several excellent options for a Caesar salad. Each place offers its own twist, so it’s worth trying a few to find your personal favorite.

Caesar Salad

More Key West Travel Questions

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions