Harbor Haus or Fitzgerald’s?

Question

If you could only do one of these restaurants, which would you choose? From where we are staying in Hancock, Harbor House is definitely farther, but the Fitzgerald’s dinner menu seems much more limited.

Answer

Choosing between Harbor Haus in Houghton and Fitzgerald’s in Hancock depends on what kind of dining experience you’re seeking, as both have their own strengths and appeal.

Harbor Haus is known for its scenic location right on the waterfront, offering views of the Portage Canal. The ambiance is relaxed yet upscale, making it ideal for a more leisurely, scenic dinner. Their menu is broader, often featuring seafood, steaks, and regional specialties, which can be appealing if you like having a variety of options and a slightly more refined dining experience. It’s also a popular spot for both locals and visitors, so reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

Fitzgerald’s, on the other hand, is closer to Hancock and may be more convenient if you prefer a short drive. The menu is smaller and more focused, typically featuring comfort food, local ingredients, and classic American dishes. The setting is cozy and casual, giving it a friendly, neighborhood feel. While the selection is more limited, many patrons appreciate the quality of the dishes and the welcoming service.

If your priority is a scenic waterfront experience with a varied menu, Harbor Haus is likely the better choice, even with the extra drive.
If convenience, casual comfort, and a shorter drive are more important, Fitzgerald’s offers a solid, cozy meal without the need to travel far.
Consider timing: if you plan to go at peak dinner hours, Harbor Haus may require reservations, while Fitzgerald’s may be easier to get into last-minute.

Ultimately, if you only have time for one and are willing to drive a bit, Harbor Haus provides a memorable dining experience with a view and broader menu options. Fitzgerald’s is great for a low-key, straightforward dinner, especially if staying in Hancock or preferring a more intimate, local vibe.