Buying fresh fish

Question

We are staying at Honua Kai and wanting to buy fresh fish to grill at the condo today (Sunday). Where is a good place within 5 miles or so to get fish? Is it good from Times Supermarket? Prefer a fish store though.

Answer

If you're staying at Honua Kai and are looking to buy fresh fish to grill at the condo, you're in luck, as Maui has several great options for fresh seafood. Here's a rundown of some excellent places within about 5 miles of your location to get quality fish:

1. Paia Fish Market

Located in Lahaina, just a short drive from Honua Kai, Paia Fish Market is known for its fresh, locally caught fish and casual vibe. They offer a variety of seafood, including ahi tuna, mahi-mahi, ono, and more. The fish is fresh and perfect for grilling. They also have ready-to-cook meals if you're looking for something easy.

2. Honokowai Seafood

This local seafood market is a great spot for fresh fish just a few miles from Honua Kai. They offer a variety of fresh catch, including mahi-mahi, ono, ahi, and more. If you're after a traditional fish market experience with excellent customer service and a great selection of fish, Honokowai Seafood is a good choice. It's located near the Honokowai Beach Park area, so it's very convenient.

3. Times Supermarket (Honokowai)

Times Supermarket in Honokowai is a convenient option if you're looking for a one-stop shop. While not a dedicated fish market, their seafood section often has a good selection of fresh fish. The quality is generally good, and it’s an easy stop if you don’t want to go out of your way. It’s a good option for getting fish if you don’t mind the supermarket setting.

4. Maui Fresh Fish

Maui Fresh Fish is another great option for fresh fish on the island. They specialize in locally caught fish and have a wide range of selections. If you’re looking for top-quality, freshly caught seafood, this is an excellent place to visit. It's a bit further down in the Lahaina area but definitely worth the trip if you're after something specific or particularly fresh.

5. Costco (Kahului)

If you're willing to drive a bit further (about 30 minutes from Honua Kai), Costco in Kahului has an excellent seafood section with very fresh fish at competitive prices. While it’s a larger chain, their fish is usually of good quality, and it’s a great place to stock up if you're planning to grill a lot of fish during your stay.

In Summary:

Paia Fish Market – A great option for fresh fish in Lahaina with a casual atmosphere.
Honokowai Seafood – A local fish market close to Honua Kai with a good variety of fresh seafood.
Times Supermarket (Honokowai) – Convenient, though a supermarket, it still offers a decent selection of fresh fish.
Maui Fresh Fish – Excellent selection of locally caught fish, though it may require a bit more driving.
Costco (Kahului) – If you're okay with a longer drive, Costco has fresh fish at a good price.

All of these are solid choices for picking up fresh fish for grilling at your condo. Happy cooking and enjoy your fresh Hawaiian fish!