Anniversary dinner
Looking for a quiet restaurant for our 44th anniversary. Probably not seafood since we just spent the last 3 days in Key West. We like to stay under a $ 100.00 for both of us, I don't drink so no wine etc will be drunk. Thank you!
Happy 44th anniversary! Congratulations — that’s wonderful. Naples has a number of charming, relatively affordable restaurants that are great for a quieter, romantic dinner without breaking the $100 total budget (especially since you’re not ordering wine). Here are several suggestions plus some tips to help you pick the right spot.
- Pazzo! Cucina Italiana — This is a warm, classic Italian restaurant on Fifth Avenue South. Known for its handmade pastas and comforting Italian dishes, the OpenTable “Value” list shows that many entrées are under $30.
- The 239 Naples — They offer a 3-course dinner for about $49/person (before tax + tip). Depending on how you order, you can definitely stay under $100 for both of you. Their menu includes pasta, vegetarian bowls, and a few meat options.
- Bicyclette Cookshop — A newer New American restaurant in Naples (Vanderbilt Beach area) with a creative, shareable small-plates style. Reddit users recommend it as a good spot that’s “not so crazy prices.” The ambiance is relaxed yet thoughtful — perfect for an anniversary dinner that feels special without being too formal.
- Ristorante Machiavelli — A cozy, neighborhood Italian spot that’s known for its consistent quality and old-school charm. The prices are reasonable for classic Italian fare, making it a sweet choice for a quiet, romantic evening.
- Aji Limon — According to locals on Reddit, this is a “good spot … pretty inexpensive.” While it has some seafood, it also offers other dishes, and the laid-back vibe is great for a relaxed anniversary dinner.
Other Tips & Suggestions:
- Call ahead and check the menu: Menus sometimes change, so it’s smart to verify current prices to make sure you’ll stay within your budget.
- Consider dining early: Many restaurants offer early evening dinner specials, which can make the evening more affordable.
- Choose shared appetizers or small plates: At places like Bicyclette, sharing a few small plates can make the meal feel special — and help control cost.
- Ask for a quiet table: When making a reservation (or arriving), mention that it’s your anniversary — many spots will be happy to seat you somewhere more intimate.
My Recommendation: Given your anniversary and budget, The 239 Naples or Pazzo! Cucina Italiana feel like the best fits. The 3-course deal at The 239 is particularly appealing for a celebratory dinner, and Pazzo! offers classic Italian fare with a cozy, romantic feel.
More Naples Travel Questions
- Naples Park
- Best hotel for girls trip with a great pool
- Itinerary ideas 2025
- Happy Hours
- Night time frog chorus
- Manatees
- Any Naples hotels with indoor pools?
- Fishing charter and sunset sail
- How is recovery going? Should I visit?
- looking for resort/hotel with pickleball courts/ instructors
- Has red tide appeared this year
The attractions mentioned in this question
Popular Destinations
Popular Travel Questions
- Dog Friendly Question
- Virgina City Inn
- Budget Car rental Kailu-Kona Airport
- Route 22 - Monterey to Nepenthe - not running?
- Breakfast between Punta gorda and sannibel
- Joshua Tree National Park - week of Jul 28
- I have multiple chemical sensitivity, is this hotel ok?
- Two night stay suggestion?
- Weekend in & around Arcadia, CA?
- Best way to get to Dunhuang from Xi'an
- Pollen & Augusta national golf
- Transportation and lodging in Granby