Renaissance Historic downtown vs the Hilton bayfront histori

Question

Have narrowed it down to these two..would be booking balcony rooms …the Hilton is about $200 more for 3 nites .Which has the best location ? We will be there in early October so it will be still hot …don’t want to walk more than I need to.. All input appreciated

Answer

Both the Renaissance Historic Downtown and the Hilton Bayfront Historic are excellent options in St. Augustine, and your decision largely depends on how much you value location and views versus overall cost. Here’s a breakdown to help you decide:

Location Comparison:

Renaissance Historic Downtown:
- The Renaissance is located in the heart of historic downtown St. Augustine, making it very central for exploring the city’s main attractions. You’ll be close to Flagler College, the Lightner Museum, the historic district, and many of the city’s charming shops and restaurants. You’ll also have easy access to the Old City Gates and the waterfront.
- This location is great if you want to be immersed in the historic downtown vibe and don’t mind walking around the charming streets. However, it might require a short walk to the waterfront or more outlying attractions like Castillo de San Marcos.
Hilton Bayfront Historic:
- The Hilton Bayfront is situated directly on the waterfront along the Matanzas Bay, offering stunning views of the bay and the Castillo de San Marcos. It’s just a few steps from the bayfront park and about a 5-minute walk to the heart of historic downtown.
- This location is ideal if you want to be closer to the bay and the waterfront area. You’re also close to the St. Augustine Bayfront, which offers pleasant strolling areas along the water. The Hilton’s location might be slightly more convenient if you prefer easy access to the bay and want to be closer to attractions like the historic fort and bayfront shops.

Balcony Views: If having a balcony with a view is important to you, both hotels offer great options. However, given the Hilton’s prime location on the bay, you’ll likely get better waterfront views here, with views of the Castillo de San Marcos and the bay itself. The Renaissance offers balcony rooms as well, but they may overlook the city or the historic district rather than the bay.

Walking Distance & Heat in October: Considering that it will still be warm in early October, both hotels are conveniently located for walking to major sites, but if you prefer to avoid too much walking, the Hilton Bayfront might be a better option. From the Hilton, you can easily access the waterfront and nearby attractions without much walking. The Renaissance, while central, may require a bit more walking to reach the bayfront or waterfront areas in the heat.

Cost Considerations: You mentioned that the Hilton is about $200 more for 3 nights. This price difference is likely due to its superior waterfront location and views, which are a premium in St. Augustine. If the bayfront views and proximity to the water are worth the extra cost to you, it’s a solid choice. However, if you’re looking to save a bit, the Renaissance is still centrally located with easy access to historic attractions and will give you a great experience, just with slightly less of the waterfront charm.

Overall Recommendation:

If you prioritize being close to the water, stunning views, and are willing to pay a bit extra, the Hilton Bayfront Historic is the better choice. It offers great views, a prime location for exploring both the waterfront and the historic district, and easy walking distances to the main attractions.
If you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option while still being close to everything, the Renaissance Historic Downtown is a fantastic option, offering central access to historic sites, charming streets, and dining, with only a short walk to the waterfront.

Both hotels are wonderful options, so it depends on your preference for location and views versus cost. Either way, you’ll be in a prime spot to explore the best of St. Augustine!

Renaissance Historic downtown vs the Hilton bayfront histori

More St. Augustine Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions