First time Florida - HELP

Question

Hi all,

We're a couple (43 & 41) flying into MCO for 12 days in Sept/Oct.

Not interested in any theme parks or family orientated places/resorts.

We're looking for ideally off the beaten track places. Happy to stay all 11 nights in one place, or perhaps two. I say this as we are still debating transport. Whether to hire car, or perhaps use trains. We dont have to be in Orlando, so Florida really is our oyster. Small budget too.

Any ideas on itinerary?

Answer

Hi there! Florida offers a wide variety of off-the-beaten-path destinations that are perfect for a couple looking to explore beyond the typical theme park experience. Since you're interested in avoiding the tourist crowds and keeping your budget in mind, here are some itinerary ideas that focus on unique, quiet spots with a lot of charm.

First, as you mentioned, you’re still debating whether to rent a car or use trains. For more flexibility, renting a car would be ideal, as it allows you to easily explore Florida's natural beauty and small towns. While Florida does have some train services, they are limited, and public transportation options outside of major cities can be sparse. A rental car would also give you the freedom to explore areas that are less touristy and more laid-back.

Here’s an itinerary suggestion for a 12-day trip that combines relaxation, nature, and authentic Florida charm:

Day 1-4: St. Augustine — Start your adventure in St. Augustine, the oldest city in the U.S. It's a charming destination with cobblestone streets, historical architecture, and stunning coastal views. You can explore Castillo de San Marcos, take a scenic walk along the historic district, and visit the beautiful St. Augustine Lighthouse. The city has a great selection of cozy bed-and-breakfasts, and there are plenty of quiet beaches like Anastasia State Park to unwind on.
Day 5-7: Amelia Island — Head north to Amelia Island, a peaceful getaway that feels worlds away from the busy tourist spots. You can visit Fort Clinch State Park for a day of nature walks, enjoy the island’s pristine beaches, and explore Fernandina Beach, a quaint town with Victorian architecture and great local restaurants. Amelia Island offers a more laid-back, rustic Florida experience.
Day 8-10: Crystal River and the Nature Coast — If you enjoy outdoor activities and nature, head to Crystal River, known for its manatee population. It's a great place for kayaking, boating, and swimming in the crystal-clear springs. You can also visit the nearby Homosassa Springs Wildlife State Park or take a manatee tour in the Crystal River National Wildlife Refuge. The area offers a quiet, rural vibe perfect for relaxing and enjoying nature.
Day 11-12: Sarasota and Siesta Key — End your trip with a visit to Sarasota and Siesta Key. Sarasota has a laid-back, artistic atmosphere with its galleries, botanical gardens, and downtown area filled with boutiques and cafes. Siesta Key is home to one of the most beautiful beaches in the U.S., perfect for unwinding before you head back. The beaches here are peaceful, and the area is far removed from the tourist crowds of other Florida destinations.

If you'd prefer to keep your itinerary simple and not drive too much, you could choose a central location like Sarasota and use it as a base to explore nearby natural attractions, such as Myakka River State Park or the beaches of Anna Maria Island. From there, you can take day trips to nearby locations without the need to change hotels.

In summary, your itinerary could look like this: