Shephard's or Hyatt if they were the same price?

Question

Which resort would you choose if they were the same price? Looking for some fun places around with live music (I know Shephard's has it daily) but if Hyatt is a lot nicer we could stay there if there are some fun places around there. Thoughts? Thanks!

Answer

When deciding between Shephard’s Beach Resort and the Hyatt in Clearwater, it really comes down to the type of vacation experience you want, especially since you mentioned live music and nightlife.

Shephard’s Beach Resort is famous for its daily live music, vibrant nightlife, and social atmosphere. It’s right on Clearwater Beach, giving easy access to bars, restaurants, and beach activities. If your main priority is an energetic, fun-filled vacation with entertainment and a party vibe, Shephard’s is hard to beat. The resort has a pool, beachfront access, and casual dining, but the accommodations may be more standard compared to a full-service hotel like the Hyatt.

The Hyatt, on the other hand, offers a more upscale, modern hotel experience with spacious rooms, refined amenities, and quiet, family-friendly or couple-focused spaces. While it may not have daily live music on-site, it is still within walking distance or a short ride to Clearwater Beach attractions, restaurants, and nightlife. If you prefer a higher-end stay with more comfort and luxury, the Hyatt could be the better option, with live music and entertainment accessible nearby rather than directly on-site.

Shephard’s Beach Resort – Pros: daily live music, lively nightlife, beachfront pool and activities, casual dining, social atmosphere. Cons: rooms may be simpler, more party-oriented environment, less privacy.
Hyatt Clearwater Beach – Pros: upscale accommodations, spacious rooms, full-service amenities, quieter atmosphere, still close to dining and nightlife. Cons: no daily live music on-site, may require walking or driving to entertainment.

Additional considerations:

If your priority is on-site entertainment and a fun, energetic environment, Shephard’s offers everything in one place.
If you value comfort, modern rooms, and a more relaxed or romantic stay but still want access to bars and music nearby, the Hyatt is a strong choice.
Both resorts are on or very close to Clearwater Beach, so regardless of choice, you’ll have access to the beach, water sports, and local attractions.

In summary, for a vacation focused on daily live music and a party vibe, Shephard’s Beach Resort is the ideal pick. For a more refined, upscale stay with comfort and convenience, while still being close to fun spots, the Hyatt would be the better choice. Since you mentioned both are the same price, it ultimately depends on whether you want an active social scene or a more relaxed, comfortable experience.