Dont shoot me
Hey please don't shoot me for not doing research 1st but i need help getting the ball rolling. I know Maui like the back of my hand and absolutely love the island. However, I want to explore Th BI this time for 7-10 days and the head to Maui for a week to relax. Can someone point me in the direction of areas on the BI to start my research and maybe even time of year?
Completely open to budget
Prefer to stay away from high rises
Will rent a car
Active
Care about culture, scenery and beauty
If it helps, this is our kind of trip to Maui nowadays:
Kapalua Bay, specifically Oneloa beach.
Laying on the very unpopulated beach
Shorter hikes
maybe a jazz night at the chocolate factory or some agave at Waikulu. Bottom line, low key!
Grilling at home while watching the sunset.
Sure we love Whales and will always opt to go during that season if possible but have been at all different times of the year.
So, excuse my ignorance, I am just having a hard time getting started on my BI trip planning.
The Big Island can feel overwhelming to plan because it’s so large, diverse, and different from Maui — but based on what you love (quiet beaches, low-key nights, nature, culture, sunsets at home, and no high-rises), you are absolutely choosing the right island. Once you understand the “regions,” planning becomes much easier.
The Big Island is split into two main visitor bases: Kona side (dry, sunny, beaches) and Hilo side (lush, waterfalls, volcano). You can stay in one area your whole visit or split your time. With 7–10 days, a split stay is often ideal. Below is a structured way to start your research.
Best areas to consider for your style:
- South Kohala Coast (Puakō, Mauna Lani, Waikoloa Beach areas) – Sunny, calm waters, small low-rise communities, good for sunset grilling, beautiful beaches.
- North Kohala (Hawi / Kapaʻau) – Quiet, artsy, deeply cultural, green scenery, no high rises, excellent for a peaceful base.
- South Kona / Captain Cook – Coffee country, low-key rural feel, great snorkeling, local vibe.
- Volcano Village – Adjacent to Volcanoes National Park, cooler temps, rainforest feel, perfect for 1–2 nights if you want to explore the park deeply.
What each region offers (to help you decide your base):
If you want something similar to Kapalua’s calm natural beauty and low-key vibe, the closest match is North Kohala or the Puakō/Mauna Lani area. Very relaxed, not crowded, peaceful waters, and minimal development.
- Puakō & Mauna Lani – Incredible coral reefs, quiet beaches, luxury but understated, gorgeous lava-rock scenery. Great for grilling at home & sunset views.
- Hawi / Kapaʻau – Think artsy cafés, local galleries, strong Hawaiian culture, lush valleys nearby (Pololū), and rural roads. A wonderful slow-down area.
- Captain Cook / Kealakekua – Green, peaceful, close to great snorkeling like Two Step, local farms, and relaxed dining.
- Kona Town (NOT recommended for your vibe) – More built-up, more traffic, more condos. You can visit but you probably won’t want to stay here.
Time of year considerations:
- Winter (Dec–Mar): Whale season, mild weather, busiest and priciest but also magical if you love whales — the Kohala Coast is excellent for spotting them.
- Spring (Apr–Jun): One of the best seasons — great weather, no crowds, pleasant ocean conditions.
- Summer (Jul–Aug): Warm, calm waters, more families, but still not crowded like Maui or Oahu.
- Fall (Sep–Nov): Super quiet, excellent snorkeling conditions, usually lower prices.
Short hikes you might enjoy (fits your “active but not all-day treks” style):
- Pololū Valley Lookout & Awini Trail – Can do a short descent to the beach or walk the ridge trail for big views.
- Puakō Petroglyph Archaeological Preserve – Easy, fascinating cultural walk among lava-carved petroglyphs.
- Kealakekua Bay trails – Several short scenic walks above the bay.
- Waipio lookout – View only now unless noticing updated access rules, but still fantastic.
- Volcanoes NP short trails – Devastation Trail, Sulfur Banks, Kilauea Caldera overlook paths.
Beaches that match your “quiet and beautiful Kapalua/Oneloa-type feel”:
- Waialea Bay (Beach 69) – Calm, scenic, great shade, not overly crowded.
- Makaiwa Bay (Mauna Lani) – Peaceful, clear water, perfect for lounging.
- Hapuna (early or late in the day) – Big soft-sand beach; can feel empty at the right times.
- Maniniʻowali (Kua Bay) (go early) – Stunning turquoise water, great for swimming.
Evenings + low-key activities you may enjoy:
- Kona Brewing or Ola Brew for chill drinks.
- Local farm tours (coffee, chocolate, vanilla, mac nuts).
- Stargazing on Mauna Kea slopes (not summit) — bring warm layers.
- Outdoor sunset grilling at your rental — many homes on the Kohala Coast have lanai views.
Suggested itinerary structure (easy planning starting point):
- Option A (most relaxing): 7–10 days in Puakō/Mauna Lani or North Kohala, then a week in Maui.
- Option B (see more variety): 5 nights Kohala Coast + 2 nights Volcano Village + 2–3 nights Captain Cook.
- Option C (super quiet & cultural): 6 nights North Kohala + 2 nights Volcano + 1–2 nights Kealakekua.
Why the Big Island is perfect for your “low-key Maui” style:
You’ll get wide-open beaches, room to breathe, few high rises (almost none on the Kohala coast), incredible views, and tons of local culture — all without crowds. You can wake up, drink coffee on your lanai, take a short scenic drive to a beach where you have space, grill dinner at home, and enjoy a quiet sunset. It’s the ideal mix of beauty and calm.
More Island of Hawaii Travel Questions
- Driving after dark from Maunakea to Volcano
- early February itinerary
- Island circle drive from Westin Hapuna
- Which way to vnp from kailua kona
- Hotel recommendation
- Hāpuna Beach Question
- Manta Ray Tours
- Leisure morning walks with scenery
- Help with route to/from Volcano/Hilo (Gypsy/Shaka)
- Volcano Eruption today
- Coffee Tasting in Hilo
- Where to stay on Big Island - first time?
