Manta Ray snorkeling

Question

So many options …

We are staying at Hilton Waikoloa and we have a car .

There is currently a Groupon that seems to be half the cost of other sites but I’m Leary . Can everyone please recommend the outfitter they used and their experience or are they are the same ?

Answer

Good question. You’re right — there are *many* manta snorkel tour operators out of Kona (the Big Island), and prices vary a lot. Some Groupon deals look very tempting, but it’s smart to be cautious. Below is a breakdown of what to watch out for, plus some of the most well-regarded manta tour companies, pros and cons, and my thoughts on whether to use a “budget” deal or go with a premium operator.

Things to Consider When Comparing Manta Tour Operators

Safety & Guides: Experienced operators with good safety records, well-maintained boats, and trained guides are worth paying more for. Manta snorkeling at night involves plankton, lights, and staying afloat — having pros who know what they’re doing is important.
Boat Size & Group Size: Smaller group tours often feel more personal, but very large boats may bring more people. The number of people in the water can affect how “intimate” the experience feels.
Equipment Quality: Make sure the tour provides good snorkel gear, wetsuits, and dive lights. Cheaper tours might skimp on newer gear.
Ride Time: Where the manta feeding “station” is located matters. Some tours depart very close, others have a longer ride. Shorter rides are better especially if anyone in your group is prone to seasickness.
Re-ride or Guarantee Policy: Some companies offer a “manta guarantee” (go again if you don’t see mantas) — which is very helpful because, although mantas are common, they’re wild animals and sightings are never 100%.
Environmental Practices: Good operators follow guidelines to minimize their impact on manta rays, use proper mooring, and don’t harass the animals.
Cancellation / Refund Policy: Better operators will have fair policies in case of bad weather or “no mantas” nights.

Top Recommended Manta Tour Operators (and Key Differences)

Here are several reputable manta-snorkel outfits, plus what makes each one special. These are good alternatives (or benchmarks) to compare against whichever Groupon deal you're considering.

Kona Ocean Adventures — Very experienced, family-friendly. Their manta snorkeling tour includes wetsuit, LED light boards, small-to-medium groups, and reliable manta sighting rates.
Manta Adventures — Runs a “safe & clean” newer boat (Maheli-Heli), good reputation, and has guided manta night snorkel tours.
The Manta & Snorkel Company — Very small groups (just 6 guests), which makes for a more personal experience. Their focus on guide quality, guest safety, and conservation is strong.
Big Island Divers — Known for their professionalism and safety; they don’t allow life jackets during the manta snorkel (you hold onto a floating raft) to minimize risk to mantas. They also have a “manta guarantee” — if you don't see mantas, they’ll try to rebook or offer a partial refund (check their policy).
Manta Ray Dives of Hawaii (EcoAdventures) — Offers snorkel and scuba, private charters, and a strong eco-ethos.
Kona Snorkel Tours / Kona Manta Tours — Very affordable (their site lists $99 per ticket), small run group size, and they emphasize getting to the manta site quickly (shorter boat ride) so you spend more time in the water.

What People Say (User Feedback)

On Reddit, several users prefer Big Island Divers for their reliability and safety: > “We’ve done Big Island Divers twice now … like a shop that can take us all out together.”
Others highlight Sea Paradise for small boat rides and more intimate manta encounters, especially if prone to seasickness: > “the manta rays were literally touching us … very short boat ride that stayed in a bay … good for motion sickness.”
Some prioritize smaller group, eco-friendly excursions: > “We have loved Anelakai Adventures … Out of Keauhou … felt less invasive than the big boats.”

Should You Use the Groupon Deal?

Maybe — but with caution. Here’s how to evaluate whether it’s a good deal or too risky:

Check which operator the Groupon is actually for (or sub-contracted). Is it a well-known company or a lesser-known “budget” brand? If it's a budget group, what is their safety record and gear quality?
Ask whether the Groupon offer includes everything: wetsuit, lights, snorkel gear, safety briefing, and board for holding onto in the water.
Confirm the cancellation / no-manta policy for that Groupon deal. If you don’t see mantas, can you re-book? Is there a refund?
Read recent reviews (TripAdvisor, Google) for the exact tour version that Groupon is selling — not just the company name.
Consider the “value vs. peace of mind”: saving money is great, but a highly rated, eco-focused operator might make the experience far more meaningful and less stressful.

My Recommendation (Given Your Stay at Hilton Waikoloa)

- Since you have a car and are staying at the Hilton Waikoloa, you’re well-positioned for any Kona manta tour — drive time is moderate. - Personally, I lean toward a reputable operator like Kona Ocean Adventures, Big Island Divers, or Manta Adventures rather than the cheapest Groupon, especially for a once-in-a-lifetime experience. - If the Groupon is for one of the well-known operators (or a trusted “budget branch”), and it clearly includes gear + safety + a solid cancellation / sighting policy — it *could* be worth it. But don’t book it just because it's “half price” without verifying those details.

Bottom Line

Yes — the manta snorkel are “all the same spot” in terms of where the mantas feed, but *how you experience it* matters a lot (boat, guide, group size, gear, safety). I strongly recommend choosing a well-reviewed, experienced operator. If you go with the Groupon, make sure you understand exactly which tour you're getting and the trade-offs. This is one of those Big Island experiences that is truly magical — and getting the right operator can make it even more memorable.

Manta Ray snorkeling

More Island of Hawaii Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions