Hotel help

Question

I’m coming to the island for the first time with my spouse. Staying for three nights in August. I’m having a hard time deciding on a hotel. Want a water view with sunset. Top 3 choices are Grand, Iroquois and Chippewa. Like grand as it seems everyone thinks it’s the best, Iroquois for the boutique and Chippewa for location. Any help would be much appreciated.

Answer

It sounds like you're in for a wonderful time on Mackinac Island! Each of the three hotels you're considering—The Grand Hotel, Iroquois, and Chippewa—offers something special, so let me break down their strengths to help you make a decision.

1. The Grand Hotel

The Grand is undoubtedly the most iconic hotel on Mackinac Island, known for its historic charm and old-world luxury. It boasts the world’s longest porch, offering fantastic views of the Straits of Mackinac, especially during sunset. This hotel offers a classic, upscale experience, with elegant rooms, a rich history, and stunning views. If you're looking for a grand and traditional atmosphere, this could be the right choice. The Grand Hotel is a bit of a splurge, but if you're after that iconic, luxurious experience, it’s a fantastic option.

Pros: Iconic, elegant, large porch with sunset views, great on-site dining, luxurious atmosphere.
Cons: It’s a large hotel, which may feel a bit more crowded compared to smaller boutique hotels.

2. Iroquois Hotel

The Iroquois is a smaller, boutique hotel located on the water's edge with fantastic views of the harbor and sunset. If you're seeking a quieter, more intimate experience with a personal touch, the Iroquois might be a better fit. It’s known for its excellent customer service and charm. Its water-facing rooms provide great views, and it's just a short walk to downtown. You’ll get a peaceful stay without sacrificing proximity to all the main attractions of Mackinac Island.

Pros: Boutique atmosphere, great service, peaceful yet close to downtown, wonderful sunset views.
Cons: Smaller, fewer amenities compared to The Grand, but more personalized experience.

3. Chippewa Hotel

The Chippewa Hotel is known for its fantastic location right by the harbor, offering easy access to downtown Mackinac Island. It’s a great choice if you want to be in the heart of the island’s activity while still enjoying waterfront views. The hotel’s location is a huge advantage, especially if you’re planning to do a lot of exploring on foot, as it’s centrally located. The Chippewa is a more budget-friendly option compared to The Grand, but you’ll still enjoy great views and a comfortable stay.

Pros: Best location for exploring downtown, walking distance to shops and restaurants, water views.
Cons: It’s not as luxurious or quiet as the Iroquois or Grand Hotel, more of a mid-range option.

Final Thoughts:

Here’s a quick breakdown based on what you're looking for:

If you want luxury and a grand, traditional experience with stunning views and space to relax: The Grand Hotel is your top choice.
If you prefer a smaller, more intimate boutique experience with fantastic sunset views: The Iroquois Hotel offers that perfect balance.
If location and easy access to downtown Mackinac Island are a priority: The Chippewa Hotel offers an unbeatable location right by the harbor.

Ultimately, it depends on what kind of atmosphere you’re looking for—luxury and tradition, boutique and peaceful, or centrally located and convenient. All three options offer beautiful views and a memorable experience, so you can't go wrong!