Napili Shores or Maui Kaanapali Villas

Question

Hi, My daughter and I are staying in Maui 6/17 - 6/23. I am trying to decide between Napili Shores or Maui Kaanapali Villas. We prefer not to have a big resort feel and more low-key, but do want easy access to a swimmable beach. We plan to be out and about most of the day, but will be back in the evenings for a swim, sunset viewing, etc. So far, we plan to do the Road to Hana, and surf a few days, beginners style.

Any preferences between the two resorts?

Thank you!

Answer

Both Napili Shores and Maui Kaanapali Villas are excellent options if you’re seeking a more relaxed, low-key experience rather than a large resort atmosphere. Each has its strengths depending on your priorities for beach access, amenities, and overall vibe.

Napili Shores:

Located on Napili Bay, which is known for calm, swimmable waters—ideal for an evening swim or beginners’ snorkeling.
The property is smaller and quieter than most resorts in the Kaanapali area, giving a more intimate feel and less crowds.
Rooms tend to be cozy, and many have kitchenettes, which is convenient for light meals.
The beach is right out the front, making it easy to pop in for sunset views or a quick swim after your daytime adventures.
Restaurants and shops are within walking distance, but overall the area has a more residential, relaxed vibe.

Maui Kaanapali Villas:

Located on Kaanapali Beach, closer to Whalers Village and other amenities, giving easier access to dining and shopping options.
Also a low-rise property with a quieter atmosphere compared to the big resorts along Kaanapali, but slightly busier than Napili Shores.
Rooms are spacious and usually come with full kitchens, which is great if you want to cook your own meals.
Beach is swimmable, though some areas can have moderate surf depending on conditions, so check daily.
Being close to Lahaina makes it convenient if you plan to explore restaurants and galleries in the evenings.

Considerations:

If you prioritize a quieter, more tucked-away location with easy, calm beach access for evening swims, Napili Shores is likely the better choice.
If you prefer being closer to restaurants, shopping, and a bit more energy in the evenings while still maintaining a low-key stay, Maui Kaanapali Villas is ideal.
Both properties are well-suited for evening relaxation after full days exploring Hana, surfing, or other Maui adventures.

In summary, for your plan of spending most of the day out and wanting a calm beach to return to in the evenings, Napili Shores offers a slightly quieter, more intimate experience with excellent beach access, while Maui Kaanapali Villas provides convenience and proximity to Kaanapali’s dining and shopping without feeling like a massive resort.