Monkeypod or Tommy Bahama?

Question

If you had to choose one, which one would you choose?

Answer

Choosing between Monkeypod Kitchen and Tommy Bahama Restaurant in Maui really depends on what type of dining experience you’re looking for, as both are excellent but offer different vibes and menus.

Monkeypod Kitchen:

Known for its farm-to-table approach with locally sourced ingredients, offering fresh, creative dishes.
Casual, lively atmosphere with an emphasis on craft cocktails and fresh-baked breads.
Popular for happy hour and its signature Mai Tais and fresh seafood options.
Menu is diverse, great for families or groups with varied tastes, including flatbreads, poke, fish, and desserts.
Reservations recommended during peak times, but walk-ins are often accommodated at off-peak hours.

Tommy Bahama Restaurant:

Upscale, tropical-themed dining experience with relaxed island decor.
Menu includes seafood, steaks, and tropical cocktails, but leans a bit more polished than casual farm-to-table.
Great for a more refined evening out or for a special occasion dinner.
Atmosphere is quieter, perfect for conversation or date-night vibes.
Also offers a retail store attached for some shopping before or after your meal.

If you are prioritizing a fun, casual, and food-focused experience with great cocktails and a lively vibe, Monkeypod Kitchen is probably the better choice. If you are looking for a slightly more upscale, relaxed, and scenic dinner experience, Tommy Bahama would be a solid pick. For most Maui visitors seeking a quintessential island dining experience with fresh flavors, Monkeypod is often the favorite.