Sept adult 50th bday hotel suggestion

Question

Looking for somewhere for 8 adults. Would like to be walking distance to the town. Looking at southernmost or pier house but open to other options.

Thank you

Answer

For a 50th birthday trip with 8 adults in Key West, staying within walking distance of Duval Street and the main attractions is ideal for convenience, nightlife, and dining options. Both Southernmost Beach Resort and Pier House Resort & Spa are excellent choices, but there are other options to consider as well.

Southernmost Beach Resort offers a great location at the southern end of Duval Street, with access to private beach areas, pools, and spacious rooms. It’s upscale and perfect if the group wants a mix of relaxation and proximity to nightlife.

Pier House Resort & Spa is centrally located near Mallory Square and the historic seaport. It offers a lively atmosphere with a pool, waterfront access, and easy access to sunset celebrations, restaurants, and bars. Rooms can accommodate groups, but for 8 adults, booking multiple rooms or suites will be necessary.

Southernmost Beach Resort – private beach, pools, modern rooms, excellent location for both relaxation and walking into town.
Pier House Resort & Spa – waterfront location, access to nightlife, pools, and central to many attractions.
The Marker Waterfront Resort – slightly quieter, luxury suites, great for groups, walking distance to Duval Street and restaurants.

Other options for group stays include vacation rentals and boutique hotels in Old Town Key West. Renting a large house or multiple condos can provide privacy for 8 adults, common areas to gather, and sometimes private pools. This can be more flexible and cost-effective than booking multiple hotel rooms.

Old Town Guesthouse or Historic Conch Houses – offer multiple bedrooms, communal areas, and charming Key West architecture.
Luxury vacation rentals via Airbnb or Vrbo – often provide multiple bedrooms, full kitchens, and private pools while still being a short walk to Duval Street.
Hyatt Centric Key West – newer property with modern rooms, rooftop pool, and within walking distance to Old Town attractions.

Considerations:

Check the layout and number of bedrooms if booking hotel rooms for 8; some resorts may only offer 2-3 bedroom suites, so multiple rooms may be needed.
For a milestone birthday, you might want a place with a good pool area or a private gathering space to celebrate together.
Book early, as Key West fills quickly in September and larger group accommodations can be limited.

Overall, for a mix of convenience, luxury, and accessibility to Key West’s main attractions, Southernmost Beach Resort and Pier House remain excellent choices, with vacation rentals offering additional privacy and space for a group of 8 adults.