We are coming back for a 3-night stay the 28th-31st. Found a low airfare and booked a room back at The Gardens Hotel!! The week after Fantasy Fest always seems to be a good time to visit.
~~/)~~
Visiting Key West the week after Fantasy Fest is a great choice, as the island tends to be lively but less crowded than during the festival itself. The Gardens Hotel is a lovely, central location with a relaxing atmosphere, ideal for enjoying both the charm of Old Town and the waterfront areas.
Regarding Roll Calls in Key West around October 28th–31st, these gatherings are still happening, typically informally organized by locals and travelers. While they are not officially scheduled, the social tradition continues, especially during times when tourism is high but not overwhelming.
Other tips for your visit during this period:
Overall, this timing gives you the benefit of enjoying Key West’s festive atmosphere without the large crowds, and participating in a Roll Call should be relatively easy and enjoyable during your stay.