Captain Tony's Saloon

Question

Is this place closed? It shows closed on their website.

Answer

Good question. Yes — Captain Tony’s Saloon in Key West is still open. Despite what you saw on their website, multiple sources confirm it is operating: the listed address is 428 Greene Street, and its hours and menu are active.

Evidence That It’s Open

Their menu site indicates they are open from 10:00 AM daily (with some closing later), showing regular bar hours.
Key West tourist guides still list Captain Tony’s as a historic, operating bar with live music, historic decor, and full service.
MapQuest lists the saloon’s phone number and indicates its status as “Open.”
Its Wikipedia page confirms the bar’s long history and mentions that it continues to operate under the name Captain Tony’s.

Possible Reasons Why the Website Shows “Closed”

It could be a temporary outage or maintenance issue with their website.
The website might be displaying outdated or incorrect hours — this happens sometimes with historic/local bars that don’t frequently update their site.
There may have been a mistaken or misconfigured message (“closed”) for private events or a page error.

What to Do

Call them directly at (305) 294-1838 to confirm current hours — that’s the number listed on MapQuest and multiple sources.
Check recent reviews on Google Maps, Yelp, or TripAdvisor — that’s often the best way to confirm a local bar’s open status in real time.
If you're already in Key West, stop by — it's a very walkable spot, very central, and pretty iconic. Even just to take a look inside (or grab a drink) is worth it.

Bottom Line: Captain Tony’s Saloon is not permanently closed — it’s still an operating bar with a long legacy. The “closed” message you saw is likely a website glitch or outdated info.