Cook your catch but different

Question

We got some great fish on our trip. We’ve done the standard fried or blackened and taco preparation. Does any place in Key West cook catch in a more unique style? I’m thinking something like Lazy Days sort of style?

Answer

If you're looking for unique ways to cook your catch in Key West beyond the usual fried, blackened, or tacos, you're in luck! Several restaurants in Key West offer creative and distinctive preparations for your freshly caught fish. Here are some great options:

Lazy Days Restaurant – While you mentioned Lazy Days, it's worth reiterating that they specialize in cooking your catch with a laid-back, island-style twist. One of their popular options is the "Lazy Days style" fish, which involves a savory combination of garlic, butter, and herbs, cooked with your choice of fish and served over a bed of rice or with seasonal vegetables. This approach focuses on enhancing the natural flavors of your fish with minimal fuss.
Hogfish Bar & Grill – Known for using hogfish, a local delicacy, Hogfish Bar & Grill offers unique ways to prepare your catch, including grilling, sautéing, and stuffing it with a variety of seasonings and ingredients. Their "Hogfish stuffed with crab" is a standout, blending fresh local crabmeat with the delicate flavor of the hogfish.
Key West Fisheries – For a more upscale twist, Key West Fisheries offers a gourmet approach to preparing your catch. They can prepare it in a variety of creative ways, such as in a tangy ceviche, or baked with a citrus and herb crust. If you're looking for something truly different, ask if they can prepare your fish in a Key West-style bouillabaisse, a hearty seafood stew brimming with local flavors.
The Fish House – The Fish House is another great option where you can have your catch prepared in unique ways. One of their specialties is the "Key West Grill" style, which involves grilling your fish with a special blend of spices, then topping it with a tangy, tropical fruit salsa, giving it a fresh, sweet-and-sour balance that complements the fish.
Island Grill – This restaurant specializes in tropical and Caribbean-inspired flavors. They offer unique fish dishes like "Island-style" fish, which is typically marinated in a mixture of lime juice, ginger, and tropical fruits, then grilled to perfection. This preparation method provides a balance of sweet, tart, and savory notes that pair well with any catch.

Each of these places puts a unique spin on how they prepare and cook local fish, offering something different from the traditional methods. If you're looking for a fresh and exciting take on your catch, these spots are sure to give you the unique experience you're after!

Cook your catch but different

More Key West Travel Questions

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions