Siesta Key Beach vs AMI compared to FortWaltonBeach (Destin)

Question

My family has visited Fort Walton Beach west of Destin for the past 7 years. It is less crowded and more laid back than Destin. We love it there but would like to try something new. We have heard wonderful things about both AMI and Siesta Key. Which one would most compare to the Fort Walton/Destin area (beaches, sand, water clarity and overall feel? Thanks in advance!

Answer

If you love the laid-back vibe of Fort Walton Beach but are looking to try something new, both Siesta Key and Anna Maria Island (AMI) are great options to consider. Each offers a slightly different experience but shares some similarities with Fort Walton Beach, such as beautiful beaches and a more relaxed atmosphere compared to the bustling tourist areas like Destin. Here’s a comparison of both Siesta Key and AMI to help you choose the best fit for your family:

Siesta Key:
Siesta Key is known for its powdery white sand, which is made up of 99% pure quartz. The sand is incredibly soft, and it stays cool to the touch, making it perfect for walking or lounging in the sun. The water clarity is excellent, with the Gulf of Mexico offering calm, shallow waters that are ideal for families. The beach is large and spacious, so even during busier times, it doesn’t feel overly crowded.

The vibe on Siesta Key is a bit more lively compared to Fort Walton Beach, with plenty of restaurants, shops, and bars within walking distance of the beach. It has a vibrant atmosphere but still maintains a relaxed beach town feel. The island has a great mix of quiet spots and more active areas, so you can choose your experience based on your mood.
Anna Maria Island (AMI):
AMI has a more serene, old-Florida charm. The island is quieter and less commercialized than Siesta Key, making it closer to the laid-back vibe of Fort Walton Beach. The beaches here are beautiful, with soft sand and clear water. While the beaches are less crowded, they still offer great opportunities for swimming, sunbathing, and beachcombing. The water clarity is excellent, especially around the northern part of the island.

AMI has a slower pace and is perfect for those who prefer a more low-key vacation. The island has fewer high-rise condos and more small beachfront cottages, which adds to the charming, small-town feel. While there are some restaurants and shops, it is not as commercialized as Siesta Key, which might appeal to those looking for a quieter escape.
Fort Walton Beach/Destin Comparison:
Both Siesta Key and Anna Maria Island offer some of the same qualities that you love about Fort Walton Beach, such as beautiful white sand beaches and clear Gulf waters. However, Siesta Key tends to have a more active beach atmosphere with its restaurants, bars, and shops, making it more similar to Destin in terms of a livelier beach experience. If you enjoy having a mix of peaceful beach time and accessible amenities, Siesta Key might feel like a natural transition.

On the other hand, if you’re more inclined towards a quieter, more tranquil setting, Anna Maria Island would be a better fit. The pace of life here is slower, and you’ll find less commercial development, making it a great choice for families who prefer to spend more time on the beach and in nature.

In summary, if you’re looking for something that’s closer to the Fort Walton Beach/Destin vibe but with a bit more of a lively, active beach scene, Siesta Key would be your best choice. It has the beauty and calm waters you love, along with a more vibrant atmosphere. However, if you’re after something quieter and less developed, similar to Fort Walton Beach’s slower pace, then Anna Maria Island would be a perfect choice for a peaceful, relaxing vacation.

Siesta Key Beach vs AMI compared to FortWaltonBeach (Destin)

More Siesta Key Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions