Christmas Eve & Day dinner suggestions please

What are your favorite places? I've had some really great Christmas Eve and Day dinners at Cafe Sole and La Te Da but I'm thinking about trying a new place for either night. I'll be there solo and would like to take myself out to nice dinners both nights. I know I probably need to make reservations soon-ish.

Key West has a fantastic selection of restaurants for Christmas Eve and Christmas Day dinners, offering everything from fresh seafood to upscale American and international cuisine. Since you’re traveling solo, it’s nice to choose places that are welcoming and have bar seating or cozy tables for one, along with a festive atmosphere for the holidays.

Here are some highly recommended options to consider:

  • Louie’s Backyard – An iconic waterfront restaurant offering a refined dining experience with ocean views. Their seasonal menu is perfect for a special Christmas dinner, and they have a beautiful outdoor deck if the weather is pleasant.
  • Blue Heaven – Famous for its quirky, laid-back vibe and great Caribbean-inspired dishes. While it’s popular for breakfast and lunch, their dinner service during the holidays can be a delightful, lively experience.
  • Ocean Key Resort’s Latitudes – Located at Sunset Key, it’s a short ferry ride from Key West and offers stunning sunset views with elegant seafood and steak options. Perfect for a solo dinner with a view.
  • Hot Tin Roof – Upscale but casual dining with creative seafood and steak dishes. They are known for attentive service and a great ambiance for holiday dining.
  • Seven Fish – A small, cozy seafood-focused restaurant downtown, offering fresh catches with inventive preparation. Reservations are a must during the holiday season.

Additional tips for dining in Key West during Christmas:

  • Make reservations as early as possible — many places fill up quickly for Christmas Eve and Day.
  • Check if the restaurant has a special holiday menu; some may have set prix-fixe options for the evening.
  • Consider arriving a bit earlier than usual, especially for solo dining, to get a good spot and enjoy the festive atmosphere.
  • If you prefer a more casual but equally tasty option, local seafood shacks like Conch Republic Seafood Company or Half Shell Raw Bar offer fresh local fare without the need for a strict reservation.

In summary, Key West offers a variety of excellent options for a solo traveler wanting a memorable Christmas Eve and Christmas Day dinner. Louie’s Backyard and Latitudes are top picks for a more upscale experience, while Blue Heaven and Seven Fish provide a lively, enjoyable atmosphere with fantastic food. Early reservations are essential to secure your spot.


More Key West Travel Questions