Is Tybee Island worth it?

Question

We were just in St. Simons Island, GA & we loved it! Is Tybee worth checking out? Or will I be disappointed? What area of Tybee is best to stay? Thanks so much!

Answer

Tybee Island is definitely worth considering, but it has a very different vibe from St. Simons, so your level of enjoyment will depend on what you’re looking for. St. Simons tends to feel more upscale, charming, and relaxed with a strong community atmosphere. Tybee, on the other hand, is more laid-back, quirky, and beach-town casual.

If you enjoy a simple, no-frills beach destination with a fun, slightly eclectic personality and easy access to Savannah, Tybee can be a great choice. If you prefer a more polished, village-like feel with lots of shops and manicured areas, you may find Tybee less refined than St. Simons.

Here are some key differences to help you compare:

Vibe: Tybee is casual, lively, and a bit funky; St. Simons is charming, calm, and more elegant.
Beaches: Tybee has long, wide beaches with great sunrise views; St. Simons has scenic marshes and tidal beaches that shift with the tide.
Accessibility: Tybee is only 20–25 minutes from downtown Savannah, making it ideal if you want a mix of beach and city.

If you decide to stay on Tybee, different areas offer different experiences, so choosing the right location matters a lot. Here’s a breakdown:

South Beach – This is the liveliest area with the pier, shops, and restaurants. Great for people who want to walk everywhere, but expect more noise and a more crowded beach.
Mid Beach – A quieter stretch between the busy south end and the peaceful north end. A good choice for families or anyone who wants easy beach access with fewer crowds.
North Beach – Calmer, more residential, near the lighthouse and museum. The beach is peaceful and great for watching ships, but the water can be a bit rougher.
Back River Area – Known for beautiful sunsets, dolphin sightings, and calmer waters. Ideal if you’re looking for a relaxing, scenic stay away from the bustle.

Overall, Tybee Island is worth visiting if you appreciate a more unpolished, nostalgic beach experience with friendly locals and easy access to Savannah’s historic charm. It won’t feel like St. Simons, but it has its own character that many people love.

If you enjoy exploring different coastal atmospheres, Tybee can absolutely be a fun and worthwhile addition to your Georgia coast travels.