Trying to decide on hotel...need help

Question

Family of 4 going for a long weekend in early April. Our kids are 17 and 20. They are well traveled but it will be their first time to New Orleans - along with my husband. I was there a couple times for work many years ago. Didn't get to explore a lot.

We like nicer, upscale, comfortable hotels and are willing to pay for it as long as the value is there. But we also are excited about experiencing the charm and uniqueness of New Orleans so not wanting a plain, basic, hotel that you can find in any city.

Our itinerary is still being decided but will likely revolve around walking through the different areas of the city and lots of restaurants. I see a lot of opinions around "there's more to the city than just the french quarter". But almost all of the hotel recommendations are "stay in the french quarter". So trying to understand how important it is to be in that area and if we'll potentially be missing out on something if we stay in another district but are within walking distance of the FQ. ??

I originally wanted to stay at the Eliza Jane or St. Vincent but they are both completely unavailable during our weekend. So now I've narrowed it down to Monteleone, Bienville, Omni, Sonesta, or Place D'Armes. Unless it's not really that important that we are right in the FQ?? In that case there are probably some other options we could look at.

We want something upscale and comfortable, with the charm and feel of a boutique hotel. Thoughts on my list above and which you would recommend. Thanks!

Answer

It sounds like you have a great trip ahead, and it's fantastic that you're aiming for a more unique, upscale experience in New Orleans! Let me help break down your options and the decision between staying in the French Quarter versus another neighborhood.

The French Quarter (FQ) is certainly the most iconic area of New Orleans, famous for its historic architecture, lively streets, music, and world-renowned restaurants. Many visitors choose to stay in the FQ for its proximity to landmarks like Bourbon Street, Jackson Square, the French Market, and Café du Monde. If you're looking for an immersive New Orleans experience, staying in or very close to the FQ puts you in the heart of it all.

That said, New Orleans is a vibrant city with several distinct districts, and many of them offer a more relaxed vibe while still being a short walk or quick ride from the FQ. For example, the Warehouse District and Garden District have a more local, artsy, and upscale feel, with boutique hotels, restaurants, and galleries. If you're not dead set on staying right in the FQ, these areas can offer a more “local” experience and are still very close to the action.

Now, regarding the hotels on your list:

Hotel Monteleone – This is an iconic, historic hotel in the FQ, and it's a classic choice. With its grand lobby, rooftop pool, and famous Carousel Bar, it definitely has that New Orleans charm you're seeking. It’s not as boutique as some, but it offers a luxurious experience with an undeniable sense of history and elegance.
Bienville House – A charming boutique hotel just a short walk from the FQ. It's located on a quieter street, which can be a nice break from the bustle, but you’ll still be close enough to the main attractions. It offers a great mix of comfort, character, and accessibility to the FQ.
Omni Royal Orleans – Located in the heart of the FQ, this is another classic hotel that combines luxury and a historic feel. It’s very well-regarded for its service and amenities, though it can feel a little more traditional and less unique compared to some smaller boutique options.
Sonesta New Orleans – Situated on the edge of the French Quarter, Sonesta offers a good balance of luxury and a more modern vibe compared to some of the more historic hotels. It's an upscale hotel, and while it’s in a great location, it's a bit more standard in terms of decor compared to boutique-style hotels.
Place d’Armes – This hotel has a lovely courtyard, and it’s also located within the French Quarter, close to Jackson Square. It’s a charming boutique hotel that feels authentic to New Orleans with its Creole architecture and warm atmosphere. If you're looking for a place with charm but want to avoid the more commercial feel, this is a great choice.

If you’re leaning toward the FQ, the Hotel Monteleone and Place d’Armes would be excellent choices, with the former offering a more luxurious and historic experience, while the latter provides a more relaxed, intimate boutique feel. If you’re open to staying just outside the FQ, the Bienville House and Sonesta would be great options—offering comfort and easy access to the FQ, but in a quieter environment.

In terms of the importance of being in the FQ, it's really up to how much you want to be immersed in that classic New Orleans experience. You can easily explore the FQ from the nearby neighborhoods, so it’s not a deal-breaker to stay outside of it. The Garden District and Warehouse District are great areas to stay if you want a quieter, more sophisticated vibe with easy access to local eateries, bars, and galleries.

In conclusion, staying in or near the French Quarter will give you the most central location for first-time visitors, but the choice between the neighborhoods comes down to your preference for a quieter atmosphere versus being in the heart of the action. If your focus is on charm and boutique hotels, I’d lean toward the Bienville House, Place d'Armes, or even the Monteleone for its history and character.

Have a wonderful time in New Orleans!