Help me pick 2!

Question

My husband and I plan on staying in the French Quarter. I want to try the char grilled oysters (not hubby - he is allergic). I want to try them at 2 different places and I am having a hard time picking which 2. There have been good reviews about most of them.....

That being said, if you had to pick only 2 places from my choices below, which 2 would they be -

Mr. Eds, Acme, Felix's, or Dragos (Hilton)?

Answer

What a great plan to try char-grilled oysters in New Orleans! Each of the places you’re considering has a bit of its own flavor and vibe. Since your husband isn’t able to try them, I’m sure you’ll want to find spots that offer not only great oysters but also a good atmosphere and additional options for him to enjoy. Here’s a breakdown of the options, and based on your preferences, I’d recommend two places to check out:

1. Acme Oyster House: Acme is an iconic spot in New Orleans, especially known for its oysters. It's often bustling, with a lively atmosphere and a great mix of locals and tourists. The char-grilled oysters here are a popular choice, and many people rave about the smoky, buttery flavor. Acme also offers other seafood dishes, so your husband can enjoy plenty of options. The location in the French Quarter is very convenient if you're staying nearby. It’s a fun place with a great vibe, and while it can be crowded, the experience is part of the charm.

2. Drago's Seafood Restaurant (Hilton): Drago's is another fantastic choice for char-grilled oysters. Known for their signature char-grilled oysters, Drago’s offers a slightly more upscale dining experience compared to Acme, but the flavors are just as rich. The oysters here are typically cooked to perfection with the right amount of garlic, butter, and cheese. Drago’s is also less hectic than some of the more touristy spots, and it has a great menu with other seafood dishes that your husband will enjoy. The Hilton location is modern and a bit quieter, making it a great spot for a more relaxed meal.

Why These Two? Between the two, Acme will give you that quintessential, bustling New Orleans seafood experience, perfect for tourists looking for a lively atmosphere. Drago’s, on the other hand, offers a slightly more refined and quieter environment while still delivering excellent char-grilled oysters. The combination of these two places gives you a balance of the energetic French Quarter vibe with Acme and a more laid-back but still delicious experience at Drago’s.

Other Options: If you wanted to consider other factors:

Felix's Restaurant & Oyster Bar: A solid choice with a more casual, classic oyster bar atmosphere. Felix’s has a good reputation for its oysters, and while it’s not as well-known as Acme, it offers a nice, relaxed vibe. The oysters here are always fresh, and it's a more local favorite than some of the more tourist-heavy spots.
Mr. Ed’s Oyster Bar & Fish House: A little farther from the French Quarter, but Mr. Ed’s offers great seafood and has a loyal following. The char-grilled oysters are often praised, and it’s a more laid-back, less tourist-centric spot. It’s a nice choice if you want to explore a different part of the city.

Final Recommendation: For the most iconic, well-rounded experience, I’d go with Acme for the lively vibe and Drago’s for a quieter but still exceptional char-grilled oyster experience. Enjoy your trip and your oysters!

Help me pick 2!

More New Orleans Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions