Itinerary and help in chosing island for being first time

Question

Hi im planning to visit Hawai in May, with a toddler.

5 days trip, need help to choose which island is recommended. None of us know swimming but interested in scuba diving, is that allowed by any private agency? Apart from beach, what else can be explored on the island (natural place).

Answer

It’s wonderful that you’re planning a trip to Hawaii in May! With a toddler and an interest in scuba diving (even though you don’t know how to swim yet), there are some great options for islands to visit. I'll guide you through your island options and provide some recommendations on what to do with your family while you’re there.

Choosing an Island: Given that you’re traveling with a toddler and are new to scuba diving, you’ll want an island with gentle beaches, family-friendly activities, and options for learning scuba diving in a safe, controlled environment. Here are a few island options to consider:

Oahu: Oahu is a great choice for first-time visitors. It has a mix of beautiful beaches, family-friendly activities, and the most well-developed infrastructure for tourists. Honolulu, on Oahu, is the busiest city in Hawaii, so it’s a great place for shopping, dining, and cultural attractions. The beaches here, like Waikiki, are ideal for beginners who are not strong swimmers, and there are calm areas for toddlers to play safely in the sand. Oahu also has several scuba diving schools that cater to beginners. For natural attractions, you can visit places like Diamond Head, Hanauma Bay (a protected marine embayment where you can snorkel), and the North Shore’s scenic spots.
Maui: Maui is another excellent option, particularly for families. It offers more of a laid-back vibe compared to Oahu but still has great beaches and activities. The island is known for its stunning natural beauty, including Haleakalā National Park, the scenic Road to Hana, and beautiful beaches like Wailea and Ka'anapali. Maui is also home to several scuba diving agencies that offer introductory dives for beginners in shallow, calm waters, making it a good fit for those who want to learn. Maui’s beaches tend to be calmer, and you can find some great shallow snorkeling areas with minimal waves.
Big Island (Hawai’i Island): The Big Island is more spread out and less developed than Oahu or Maui, but it offers incredible natural attractions. Volcanoes National Park, lush rainforests, and black sand beaches are just a few of the island’s highlights. For scuba diving, there are several options, and you can book beginner-friendly dives in protected bays like Kealakekua Bay, which is a calm spot to practice. Keep in mind that the Big Island’s beaches might be a little more rugged, so it may not be as ideal for toddler-friendly beach days compared to Maui or Oahu.
Kauai: Kauai, also known as the "Garden Isle," is perfect for nature lovers who want to explore lush landscapes and do less crowded hikes or activities. While it is absolutely stunning, the beaches can be more rugged and have stronger currents, so it’s not always ideal for first-time swimmers or toddlers who need more protected beach environments. However, Kauai offers beautiful natural attractions like Waimea Canyon, Na Pali Coast, and Wailua Falls. It’s also quieter and more secluded, which could be a benefit if you prefer a peaceful, low-key vacation. Kauai does have a few scuba diving options, but it’s more geared toward experienced divers due to the stronger currents.

Scuba Diving as a Beginner: Many dive shops on Oahu, Maui, and the Big Island offer Discover Scuba Diving courses for beginners, even for those who don't know how to swim. These are introductory courses where you dive in shallow waters with an instructor, and you don’t need to be a strong swimmer. If you’re looking to get into scuba diving during your trip, be sure to check with reputable dive shops about their beginner programs. For your safety and peace of mind, make sure to book with professional agencies that cater to novices and have instructors experienced in working with beginners.

Family-Friendly Activities Beyond the Beach: Besides lounging on the beach, there are plenty of other activities that you can enjoy with your toddler and family. Here are a few suggestions:

Waikiki Aquarium (Oahu): A great place for families, especially with a toddler. The aquarium features local marine life and provides educational opportunities for all ages.
Haleakalā National Park (Maui): Visit the summit of the dormant Haleakalā volcano. The sunrise and sunset views are breathtaking, and there are short, stroller-friendly walks to enjoy.
Volcanoes National Park (Big Island): This is a great place for an educational and natural experience. You can explore the Kīlauea volcano, see lava tubes, and walk along crater rims. Some trails are easy and suitable for families.
Waimea Canyon (Kauai): This stunning “Grand Canyon of the Pacific” offers dramatic views, and there are short walks along the rim that are suitable for families.

Conclusion: For first-time visitors with a toddler, Oahu and Maui are likely your best options, as they offer a mix of family-friendly beaches, nature, and activities, along with beginner-friendly scuba diving experiences. Oahu will give you more of a city vibe with cultural attractions, while Maui offers a more relaxed, scenic atmosphere. Both islands have many easy-to-access natural wonders and safe, calm beaches that your toddler will enjoy. If you prefer a more relaxed pace and access to quieter, less crowded areas, Maui could be the best choice for you.

Itinerary and help in chosing island for being first time

More Hawaii (HI) Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions