Which place?

Question

Hi. My daughter is eloping at the 1 Hotel in March. I am trying to find close accommodations because we do not want to stay where they are. I am torn between two units at the Hanalei Bay Resort or two units at Ali Kai resort. Can anyone recommend between those two? Or I am open if anyone has a different option. We are trying to sleep six other people.

Thank you!

April

Answer

Both Hanalei Bay Resort and Ali’i Kai Resort are excellent choices near the 1 Hotel on Kauai’s North Shore, but they offer slightly different experiences depending on what you prioritize.

Hanalei Bay Resort:

Located on a quieter stretch of Hanalei Bay, with beautiful mountain and ocean views.
Direct beach access and a large pool area.
Units tend to be spacious, well-maintained, and good for families or groups of six.
The property has a more laid-back, traditional Kauai vibe.

Ali’i Kai Resort:

Located closer to the heart of Hanalei town, with easy access to shops, restaurants, and activities.
Beachfront units with panoramic views and a more modern feel.
Smaller property with fewer units, which can mean a quieter, more private experience.
Good for groups who want to be within walking distance of town amenities while still having a beachfront stay.

Other considerations:

If you prefer more direct access to shops and casual dining, Ali’i Kai may be better.
If your priority is expansive views, a relaxed atmosphere, and beach access without leaving the property, Hanalei Bay Resort is ideal.
Both resorts are within a short drive of 1 Hotel, so you’ll still be nearby without staying at the same property.

Alternative options to consider for a group of six:

Private vacation rentals in the Hanalei or Princeville area, which can offer more flexibility, multiple bedrooms, and privacy.
Check VRBO or local property managers for homes with direct bay views or larger outdoor spaces for gatherings.

Overall, both Hanalei Bay Resort and Ali’i Kai Resort are solid choices; it depends on whether you value proximity to town and modern amenities (Ali’i Kai) versus space, traditional resort feel, and a more secluded beach experience (Hanalei Bay Resort).

Which place?

More Kauai Travel Questions

The attractions mentioned in this question

Popular Destinations

Popular Travel Questions